Influence of secular trends and sample size on reference equations for lung function tests

Abstract

The aim of our study was to determine the contribution of secular trends and sample size to lung function reference equations, and establish the number of local subjects required to validate published reference values.30 spirometry datasets collected between 1978 and 2009 provided data on healthy, white subjects: 19,291 males and 23,741 females aged 2.5-95 yrs. The best fit for forced expiratory volume in 1 s (FEV1), forced vital capacity (FVC) and FEV1/FVC as functions of age, height and sex were derived from the entire dataset using GAMLSS. Mean z-scores were calculated for individual datasets to determine inter-centre differences. This was repeated by subdividing one large dataset (3,683 males and 4,759 females) into 36 smaller subsets (comprising 18-227 individuals) to preclude differences due to population/technique.No secular trends were observed and differences between datasets comprising .1,000 subjects were small (maximum difference in FEV1 and FVC from overall mean: 0.30--0.22 zscores). Subdividing one large dataset into smaller subsets reproduced the above sample sizerelated differences and revealed that at least 150 males and 150 females would be necessary to validate reference values to avoid spurious differences due to sampling error.Use of local controls to validate reference equations will rarely be practical due to the numbers required. Reference equations derived from large or collated datasets are recommended.

New reference equations to improve interpretation of infant lung function

“…Similarly, although equations were formulated for C rs and R rs , these were based on only 105 sets of results, which may be insufficient to create reliable reference equations. 40 It will be important over the coming years to validate these equations using data collected in other centers, with subsequent amendments if required. 30 In addition, given the relatively low sample size, there will be a certain degree of imprecision around the calculated centiles.…”

Age- and height-based prediction bias in spirometry reference equations

“…However, the piecemeal approach of dividing the human lifespan into small sections inevitably leads to disjunctions at the age group boundaries (table 2). These arise mainly from the use of different models, which may fit the data poorly, and from the use of population samples that are often small and only poorly representative of the population [2,19]. Thus there is an urgent need for a consistent evidence-based approach towards the construction and use of reference values.…”

Proposición de nuevas ecuaciones para calcular valores espirométricos de referencia en población chilena adulta: Sociedad Chilena de Enfermedades Respiratorias (SER)

“…El contar con estas ecuaciones representativas de la población chilena, permitirá también efectuar comparaciones con las GLI2012 46 , ecuaciones multiétnicas recientemente publicadas por la Global Lung Function Iniciative (GLFI) 47 con fines epidemiológicos y de investigación 48 .…”