Influence of non-aqueous phase liquid configuration on induced polarization parameters: Conceptual models applied to a time-domain field case study

Abstract

Resistivity and induced polarization (IP) measurements on soil contaminated with non-aqueous phase liquids (NAPLs) show a great variety in results in previous research. Several laboratory studies have suggested that the presence of NAPLs in soil samples generally decrease the magnitude of the IP-effect, while others have indicated the opposite. A number of conceptual models have been proposed suggesting that NAPLs can alter the pore space in different ways, e.g. by coating the grain surfaces and thus inhibiting grain polarization, or by changing the pore throat size and thus affecting the membrane polarization mechanism. The main aim of this paper is to review previously published conceptual models and to introduce some new concepts of possible residual NAPL configurations in the pore space. Time domain induced polarization measurements were performed at a NAPL contaminated field site, and the data were inverted using the Constant Phase Angle (CPA) model and the Cole-Cole model respectively. No significant phase anomalies were observed in the source area of the contamination when the CPA inverted profiles were compared with soil sampling results of free-phase contaminant concentrations. However, relatively strong phase and normalized phase anomalies appeared next to the source area, where residual free-phase presence could be expected according to the chemical data. We conclude that depending on the NAPL configuration, different spectral IP responses can be expected. In previous research, the NAPL configurations in different samples or field sites are often unknown, and this may to some extent explain why different results have been achieved by different authors. In our field case, we believe that the NAPL forms a more or less continuous phase in the pore space of the source zone leading to an absence of IP anomalies. The increase in phase and normalized phase angle observed next to the source zone is interpreted as a degradation zone. The ongoing biodegradation may have led to a fractionation of the continuous NAPL in the outer part of the original source zone, leading to residual presence of isolated NAPL droplets in the soil pores. With such NAPL configurations, an increased polarization can be expected according to the electrochemical-and membrane polarization mechanisms. More research is needed to confirm the effects of different NAPL configuration on spectral IP parameters.

Investigations of a Cretaceous limestone with spectral induced polarization and scanning electron microscopy

“…In the geometrically connected anomaly in the main survey area (Fig. 10), the resistivity values were below 100 m. These values are in the same order of magnitude as the overlying till, but since the normalized chargeability values are elevated, the structure is not interpreted as a depression in the bedrock surface topography (see Johansson et al 2015 for details on the resistivity and IP responses of the Quaternary deposits in the same survey area).…”

“…Within the main survey area there is a property contaminated with a plume of free-phase tetrachloroethylene, which has previously been investigated with DCIP by Johansson et al (2015). However, concerns about groundwater disposal of dissolved contaminants to the surroundings remain.…”

Upscaling of spectral induced polarization response using random tube networks

“…Veeken et al 2009), location and delineation of contaminant plumes (e.g. Mewafy et al 2013;Johansson et al 2015;Ntarlagiannis et al 2016), monitoring of biodegradation processes in contaminated area (e.g. Flores Orozco et al 2011;Abdel Aal et al 2014) and even hydrological characterization of the subsurface (e.g.…”

Induced polarization applied to biogeophysics: recent advances and future prospects

“…; Johansson et al . ) and this is often attributed to microbially mediated degradation of hydrocarbons. On the contrary, there are observations with negligible polarization in the case of oversaturation of hydrocarbons and/or the presence free‐phase non‐aqueous phase liquids (NAPL; Flores‐Orozco et al .…”