Influence of Fe(II) on Arsenic(III) Oxidation by Birnessite in Diffusion-Limited Systems

Abstract

Manganese­(III/IV) oxides are naturally occurring oxidants of arsenic (As) and can transform the more mobile and toxic arsenite [As­(III)] to the less mobile and less toxic arsenate [As­(V)]. However, physical heterogeneity of soils contribute to the formation of redox transition zones which can host the interaction of Fe­(II) with Mn­(III/IV) oxides, leading to altered Mn­(III/IV) oxide reactivity. In the current study, we use a diffusion-controlled reactor to simulate such a redox interface to determine how As­(III) oxidation by the Mn­(III/IV) oxide birnessite is affected by Fe­(II) within transport-limited environments. Our results show that Fe­(II) oxidation by birnessite in diffusion-limited systems forms Fe­(III) (oxyhydr)­oxides with a range of crystallinities, with ferrihydrite being the dominant phase even in the presence of high Fe­(II) concentrations. Fe­(III) (oxyhydr)­oxide formation is concomitant with birnessite transformation and release of Mn­(II), which leads to a decrease in Mn AOS without significant alteration to Mn mineralogy. Using X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy depth-profiling analysis and scanning electron microscopy imaging, we found that even as Fe­(II) is gradually introduced to birnessite, Fe­(III) (oxyhydr)­oxide precipitates did not coat the birnessite surface uniformly upon oxidation but instead formed discrete and unevenly dispersed surface-associated phases, leaving birnessite surfaces exposed to the surrounding solution. Average oxidation state of Mn in birnessite decreased rapidly after exposure to Fe­(II) coincident with a fraction of solids transforming from hexagonal to triclinic birnessite. When As­(III) was added to the diffusion-limited Fe–Mn oxide system, our results showed that pre-exposure of birnessite to high Fe­(II) concentrations leads to a delay in the appearance of As­(V) in solution as compared to oxidation by birnessite exposed to lower Fe­(II). Additionally, the maximum steady state concentration of As­(V)aq was suppressed in the high Fe system. Taken together, these findings show that though pre-exposure of birnessite to high concentrations of Fe­(II) inhibited As­(III) oxidation by Mn oxides within these systems, the precipitation of higher total mass of Fe­(III) (oxyhydr)­oxides in the high Fe system leads to greater retention of As.

Unraveling the Mechanisms of Fe Oxidation and Mn Reduction on Mn Indicators of Reduction in Soil (IRIS) Films

“…In a column study, natural birnessite led to the precipitation of iron oxides and the release of Mn­(II), although the release rate varied . In diffusion-limited reactors, birnessite oxidized Fe­(II) primarily into ferrihydrite with lesser amounts of lepidocrocite and goethite …”

“…The fate of the Mn oxides in the presence of Fe­(II) can vary. In diffusion-limited reactors, birnessite AOS reduced from 3.9 to 3.1, and this reduction was more substantial in reactors with less Fe­(II) added . The authors hypothesized that Mn­(II) was associated with the mineral rather than had diffused away from the mineral.…”

“…38 In diffusion-limited reactors, birnessite oxidized Fe(II) primarily into ferrihydrite with lesser amounts of lepidocrocite and goethite. 39 The neoformed Fe oxides on Mn IRIS present a valuable tool for studying (trans)formation dynamics and porewater interactions of Fe oxides. The formation of Fe oxides is often studied under laboratory conditions to enable careful manipulation of the experimental conditions and to allow retrieval of the reaction products.…”

Oxidation of V(IV) by Birnessite: Kinetics and Surface Complexation

“…26,27 Manganese(IV) oxides are strong oxidants and scavengers of metal(loids) like As and Cr in terrestrial systems. 28,29 The ubiquity and reactivity of Mn IV oxides make them likely candidates to influence the fate of V in these environments. For example, elevated levels of geogenic V (>50 μg L −1 ) have been detected throughout aquifers in California.…”

“…Manganese­(IV) oxides are strong oxidants and scavengers of metal­(loids) like As and Cr in terrestrial systems. , The ubiquity and reactivity of Mn IV oxides make them likely candidates to influence the fate of V in these environments. For example, elevated levels of geogenic V (>50 μg L –1 ) have been detected throughout aquifers in California. , Many of these aquifers are subject to seasonal redox fluctuations that can lead to the accumulation of Mn IV oxides in a close spatial proximity to V. ,, However, previous studies examining the reactivity of V IV and V V with soil mineral phases ,− have not examined the role of Mn IV oxides in V IV oxidation or V V adsorption, despite their importance in controlling the fate of other metal­(loid)­s.…”