Inferring the structures of signaling motifs from paired dynamic traces of single cells

Abstract

Individual cells show variability in their signaling dynamics that often correlates with phenotypic responses, indicating that cell-to-cell variability is not merely noise but can have functional consequences. Based on this observation, we reasoned that cell-to-cell variability under the same treatment condition could be explained by a single signaling motif that deterministically maps different upstream signals into a corresponding set of downstream responses. If this assumption holds, then repeated measurements of upstream and downstream signaling dynamics in single cells could provide information about the underlying signaling motif for a given pathway, even when no prior knowledge of that motif exists. To test these two hypotheses, we developed a computer algorithm called MISC (Motif Inference from Single Cells) that infers the underlying signaling motif from paired time-series measurements from individual cells. When applied to measurements of transcription factor and reporter gene expression in the yeast stress response, MISC predicted signaling motifs that were consistent with previous mechanistic models of transcription. The ability to detect the underlying mechanism became less certain when a cell's upstream signal was randomly paired with another cell's downstream response, demonstrating how averaging time-series measurements across a population obscures information about the underlying signaling mechanism. In some cases, motif predictions improved as more cells were added to the analysis. These results provide evidence that mechanistic information about cellular signaling networks can be embedded within the dynamical patterns of single cells. Author SummaryCells use molecular signaling networks to translate dynamically changing stimuli into appropriate downstream responses. Specialized network structures, or motifs, allow cells to properly decode a variety of temporal input signals. In this paper, we present an algorithm that infers signaling motifs from multiple examples of an upstream signal paired with its downstream response in the same cell. We compare the predictive power of single-cell versus averaged time-series traces and the incremental benefit of adding more single-cell traces to the algorithm.We use this approach to understand how yeast respond to environmental stresses.