Inferring pain experience in infants using quantitative whole-brain functional MRI signatures: a cross-sectional, observational study

Abstract

Summary Background In the absence of verbal communication, it is challenging to infer an individual's sensory and emotional experience. In communicative adults, functional MRI (fMRI) has been used to develop multivariate brain activity signatures, which reliably capture elements of human pain experience. We aimed to translate whole-brain fMRI signatures that encode pain perception in adults to the newborn infant brain, to advance understanding of functional brain development and pain perception in early life. Methods In this cross-sectional, observational study, we recruited adults at the University of Oxford (Oxford, UK) and infants on the postnatal wards of John Radcliffe Hospital (Oxford, UK). Healthy full-term infants were eligible for inclusion if they were clinically stable, self-ventilating in air, and had no neurological abnormalities. Infants were consecutively recruited in two cohorts (A and B) due to the installation of a new fMRI scanner using the same recruitment criteria. Adults (aged ≥18 years) were eligible if they were postgraduate students or staff at the University of Oxford. Participants were stimulated with low intensity nociceptive stimuli (64, 128, 256, and 512 mN in adults; 64 and 128 mN in infants) during acquisition of fMRI data. fMRI pain signatures (neurologic pain signature [NPS] and stimulus intensity independent pain signature-1 [SIIPS1]), and four control signatures (the vicarious pain signature, the picture-induced negative emotion signature [PINES], the social rejection signature, and a global signal signature) were applied directly to the adult data and translated to the infant brain. We assessed the concordance of the signatures with the brain responses of adults and infants using cosine similarity scores, and we assessed stimulus intensity encoding of the signature responses using a Spearman rank correlation test. We also assessed brain activity in pro-pain and anti-pain components of the signatures. Findings Between May 22, 2013, and Jan 29, 2018, we recruited ten healthy participants to the adult cohort (five women and five men; mean age 28·3 years [range 23–36]), 15 infants to infant cohort A (six girls and nine boys; mean postnatal age 4 days [range 1–11]), and 22 infants to infant cohort B (11 girls and 11 boys; mean postnatal age 3 days [range 1–10]). The NPS was activated in both the adults and infants, and reliably encoded stimulus intensity. The NPS was activated in the adult cohort (p<0·0001) and both infant cohorts (p=0·048 for infant cohort A; p=0·001 for infant cohort B). The SIIPS1 was only expressed in adults. Pro-pain brain regions showed similar activation patterns in adults and infants, whereas responses in anti-pain brain regions were divergent. Interpretation Basic intensity encoding of nociceptive information is similar in adults and infants. However, translation of adult brain signatures to infants indicated substantial differences in infant...

Quantifying noxious-evoked baseline sensitivity in neonates to optimise analgesic trials

“…This measure does not represent all nociceptive activity across the brain and cannot be used to investigate the various aspects of pain perception ; a multi-modal approach to pain assessment is therefore important in follow-on studies (Vaart et al, 2019). However, in the absence of verbalisation, neuroimaging methods provide an objective proxy approach which has been used to infer pain perception following noxious events (Baxter et al, 2020;Duff et al, 2020;Gursul et al, 2019;Hartley et al, 2017).…”

Functional and diffusion MRI reveal the functional and structural basis of infants’ noxious-evoked brain activity

“…While this BOLD response neither directly re ects nociception, the neural process of encoding noxious stimuli 16 , nor pain perception, the unpleasant sensory and emotional subjective experience 16 , it is a pertinent and accessible feature of central importance to understanding neonates' neural responses to noxious input and the neurophysiology of the early developing pain system. This overall noxious-evoked BOLD response pattern resembles that of adults 10 and expresses the adult Neurologic Pain Signature (NPS) 17 , a multivariate fMRI signature predictive of adult verbal reports of physical pain. The overall response captures inter-individual variability in the multidimensional noxiousevoked activity, which is tightly linked to the pre-stimulation functional status of the descending pain modulatory system 18 and is likely to be driven by variability in sensory-discriminative, cognitive, and emotional aspects.…”

Functional and diffusion MRI reveal the neurophysiological basis of neonates’ noxious-stimulus evoked brain activity

“…Increasing brain coverage to include pain-relevant regions such as the amygdala and orbitofrontal cortex and networks such as the salience network would likely improve the accuracy and generalisability of neonatal resting-state based-predictions. Furthermore, as part of a recent study in adults demonstrating the predictability of individual pain sensitivity from resting-state functional connectivity 31 , the researchers have developed a Resting-state Pain susceptibility Network (RPN) signature that may also have predictive value when applied to neonates, analogous to application of the adult Neurologic Pain Signature (NPS) 37 to the neonatal population in the current study and a recent publication 17 .…”