Infants can outperform adults in pitch and timbre perception

Abstract

Adults perceive pitch with fine precision, an ability ascribed to cortical functions that are also important for speech and music perception. Infants display neural immaturity in the auditory cortex, suggesting that pitch discrimination may improve throughout infancy. In three experiments, we tested the limits of pitch and timbre perception in 66 infants and 44 adults. Contrary to expectations, we found that infants surpassed adults in detecting subtle changes in pitch in the presence of random variations in timbre, and vice versa. The results indicate high fidelity of pitch and timbre coding in infants, implying that fully mature cortical processing is not necessary for accurate discrimination of these features. The surprising superiority of infants over adults may reflect a developmental trajectory for learning natural statistical covariations between pitch and timbre that improves coding efficiency in adults, but results in degraded perceptual acuity when expectations for such covariations are violated.