Industry 4.0 benefits, challenges and critical success factors: a comparative analysis through the lens of resource dependence theory across continents and economies

Abstract

PurposeEntering a new era of digital transformation, Industry 4.0 (I 4.0) promises to revolutionize the way business has been done, providing unprecedented opportunities and challenges. This study aims to investigate empirically and comparatively analyse the benefits, challenges and critical success factors (CSFs) of Industry 4.0 across four continents and developing and developed economies.Design/methodology/approachThis study used an online survey to explore the benefits, challenges and CSFs of developed and developing economies. In order to ensure the validity of the survey, a pilot test was conducted with 10 respondents. A total of 149 participants with senior managerial, vice-presidential and directorial positions from developed and developing economies spanning four continents were invited to take part in the survey.FindingsThe study ranks benefits, challenges and CSFs across economies and continents. Further, the benefit of Industry 4.0 helping to achieve organizational efficiency and agility differed across the developing and developed economies. Furthermore, the benefit improves customer satisfaction significantly differed across continents; in terms of challenges, Employee resistance to change had a higher proportion in developing economies. The future viability of I 4.0 also differed across the continents. Regarding CSFs, there was no difference across the developing and developed economies. Finally, change management and project management vary across the continents.Research limitations/implicationsThis study contributes to a balanced understanding of I 4.0 by providing empirical evidence for comparative analysis. Moreover, it extends the concept of resource dependence theory to explain how organizations in developing economies and developed economies deploy resources to manage external condition uncertainties to implement I 4.0. Furthermore, this study provides a structural framework to understand the specific benefits, challenges and CSFs of implementing I 4.0, which can be utilized by policymakers to promote I 4.0 in their economies or continents.Originality/valueTo the best of the authors’ knowledge, no studies have empirically demonstrated the comparative analysis of benefits, challenges and CSFs across economies and continents and distinguish an original contribution of this work.

Affording digital transformation: The role of industrial Internet platform in traditional manufacturing enterprises digital transformation

“…These technologies enhance productivity, quality, supply chain management, and operational efficiency. However, existing research lacks comprehensive insights into challenges, opportunities, and best practices for digital production transformation within BPD [36] , [37] . Thorough analysis and empirical studies are needed to understand the interplay between digital technologies and manufacturing processes, enabling organizations to develop tailored strategies and roadmaps for successful digital transformation initiatives [38] .…”

Innovation 4.0 Policies in Italy: Strengths and Weaknesses of the Innovation Ecosystem of the “Transition 4.0” Plan from an International Perspective

“…However, innovation 4.0 has been less investigated from a macro perspective: Jiyu et al [33], for example, focused on the outcomes of 4.0 policies to analyze the keys to the success of innovation 4.0 on different continents; in particular, they conducted a survey involving management figures from companies in all continents to provide a structural framework of the challenges and benefits brought by innovation 4.0.…”

Framework for Implementing Industry 4.0 Projects

“…Ref. [52] empirically investigates and comparatively analyzes the benefits, challenges, and critical success factors (CSFs) of Industry 4.0 across four continents and developing and developed economies. The main finding is that the challenges change across continents; for example, in Africa, "Employee's resistance to change" is the biggest challenge, and in Europe and North America, it is "Lack of I 4.0 skills and know-how".…”

“…The authors of Ref. [52] establish in their work that the critical success factors are the same across continents: "Aligning the I 4.0 initiatives with organizational strategy", "Top management support to I 4.0 initiatives", and "Employees will be important for the success of I 4.0".…”