Indigenous Engagement in Health Research in Circumpolar Countries: An Analysis of Existing Ethical Guidelines

Abstract

In this paper, we review existing ethical guidelines that support Circumpolar Indigenous Peoples’ engagement in health research. For this study, we collated national and regional ethical guidelines addressing health research engaging with Indigenous communities. Our study found that ethical guidelines addressing Indigenous engagement in health research have emerged in Canada and the U.S.A. Currently, there are no Indigenous-specific provisions in national guidelines, or legislation concerning health research engaging Indigenous peoples, in Denmark, Finland, Greenland, Norway, Sweden, or Russia. Where guidelines exist, they show considerable variations. We conclude that guidelines are essential to ensure that research undertaken in Indigenous communities is relevant and beneficial to those communities, is conducted respectfully, and that results are appropriately contextualized and accurate. We believe that our analysis might serve as a checklist to support the development of comprehensive guidelines developed by, or at least in partnership with, Arctic Indigenous communities.

A systematic review on risk and protective factors for suicide and suicidal behaviour among Greenland Inuit

“…Much of the presented research has been done with little or no mentioning of the inclusion of the community in question. This may be caused by the inclusion of quantitative data and that many studies have been conducted in a time where there was little focus on engagement of Indigenous peoples and communities in health research [ 43 ].…”

Sámi community perspectives on the COVID-19 pandemic: a mixed methods case study in Arctic Sweden

“…2021–04467). In addition, in line with ethical guidelines in Indigenous health research [ 22 , 23 ], support for the study’s implementation was sought from Sámi stakeholders. The research plan was therefore presented to the Sámediggi (Sámi Parliament in Sweden) board and to the Sámiid Riikkasearvi, neither of them expressing any objections to the study.…”

Diving below the surface: A framework for arctic health research to support thriving communities

“…We support efforts to ensure that inequities are documented in all countries. This is a challenge as there are some countries and regions that have yet to do so systematically, such as by including ethnic identifiers in health data [97]. However, the nearly exclusive narrative of rural and Indigenous populations of the north having generally worse health than dominant cultural groups [98] often distracts from really looking below the surface, at the context of those indicators within systemic inequities, and the existence of community strengths that support wellness.…”