India's depleting groundwater: When science meets policy

Abstract

A commonly applied policy to India's ongoing depletion of groundwater is feeder separation. Introduced in Gujarat as the Jyotigram Yojana (JGY) scheme, it provides a separate and rationed electricity supply to farmers and an unrationed power supply to nonagricultural users. JGY is claimed to increase groundwater storage. By using Gujarat district-level data from 1996 to 2011 and by separately applying differencein-differences and Bayesian regressions, we find that groundwater storage has continued to decrease with JGY. We contend that our empirical results show that JGY has been implemented without adequate consideration of (1) a publication bias whereby researchers have a greater likelihood of having their results published if they are statistically significant and show a positive outcome and (2) a 'barrier' effect such that communicating evidence across science and policy divides means that evidence may not be accepted, even when true, and this limits policy advice and options.This is an open access article under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial License, which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited and is not used for commercial purposes.

Sustainable Groundwater Management in India Needs a Water‐Energy‐Food Nexus Approach

“…Gujarat (Verma and Shah 2008), Punjab and Karnataka (Mukherji 2017) have undertaken feeder segregation and effectively rationed electricity supply for agricultural users. Some programs, like Gujarat's Jyotirgram Yojana (JGY) were initially deemed successful in improving electricity supply quality and reducing groundwater extraction (Verma and Shah 2008), although later studies found no long-term impacts on groundwater tables (Chindarkar and Grafton 2019). In Punjab, feeder segregation, and a host of other measures like high-voltage distribution systems, improved electricity-related outcomes, but those measures did not have any discernible impact on groundwater use because of the increasing number of electric wells in the state (Mukherji 2017).…”

Water, Sanitation, and Hygiene (WASH) during COVID19 pandemic in India: Practicability in poor settings!

“…The lack of access to water in such settings and community, might encumber its use and thereby adversely affect hygiene. The issues of ground water depletion and/or contamination could not be overstated for the adequate piped water supply in the rural India( Chindarkar & Grafton, 2019 ; Dinesh Kumar & Shah, 2010 ). When coming to the correlation between hygiene practices and the minimum quantity of water recommended, is always debatable.…”

Delineation of groundwater potential zones for sustainable development and planning using analytical hierarchy process (AHP), and MIF techniques

“…The difference might be due to the long-years over-withdrawal of groundwater for farming works that have co-operated the groundwater harvest volume at the current environmental situation in the river basin. Access to groundwater for agricultural use is also flattering progressively week to the dangers of groundwater reduction, which has been informed by numerous studies (Chindarkar et al 2019). To avoid groundwater depletion, modifying the conventional cropping types and implementing drips, sprinklers and micro-irrigation practices may be helpful for specific areas (Wang et al 2018;Kaarakka et al 2019).…”