Incubating birds can incur high energetic costs and, when faced with a trade‐off between incubation and foraging, parents may neglect their eggs in favor of their own somatic needs. Extended incubation recesses are an example of neglect, but they are often treated as outliers and largely overlooked in studies of incubation behavior. We studied incubation rhythms of Horned Larks (Eremophila alpestris) on Hudson Bay Mountain, British Columbia, Canada, during four breeding seasons. Incubation recesses averaged 10.92 ± 0.38 min (N= 4076 2‐h periods), but we observed 70 extended recesses, ranging from 59 to 387 min in duration, at 35 nests. Although rare (<1% of all daytime recesses), extended recesses occurred in all 4 yr, were longer and more frequent in colder years (60% occurred in the two coldest years), and often occurred during inclement weather (39% occurred during three storm events). Extended recesses did not appear to compensate for long attendance periods because extended recess duration was not correlated with the duration of previous on‐bouts (P= 0.10, N= 70) or the mean on‐bout duration of the previous 2‐h period (P= 0.36, N= 70). Rather, extended recesses seemed to reflect a shift in parental investment away from their eggs and toward self‐maintenance when faced with energetically stressful conditions. Extended recesses may have reduced embryo viability; egg‐hatching rates were 91 ± 2.4% for nests where females did not take extended recesses and 81 ± 4.2% for nests where females did take extended recesses (P= 0.02, N= 56 nests). Extended recesses during incubation are rare events, but they may represent an important mechanism that allows birds to breed successfully in energetically challenging conditions.