The objective of this study was to determine the effects of extender osmolality on postthaw sperm quality and fertility in Sauger Sander canadensis. Fresh milt from 10 male Saugers was diluted by using base extenders with osmolalities of 350, 500, or 750 mOsm/kg (E350, E500, and E750, respectively) containing 10% dimethyl sulfoxide, frozen in LN 2 vapor, and stored. Sperm parameters (total motility, progressive motility, velocity, and viability) were assessed at different steps of the cryopreservation process (extended, equilibrated, and postthaw). Fertilization rates were compared between fresh and frozen sperm and at two sperm-to-egg ratios. All of the parameters that were measured, except for progressive motility, were reduced by cryopreservation. Extender 500 yielded the highest postthaw progressive motility (32.20 ± 3.86% [mean ± SD]) and velocity (84.97 ± 16.82 μm/s), whereas both E350 and E500 displayed the highest total motility (65.30 ± 4.24 and 68.70 ± 6.46%) and viability (80.60 ± 4.84 and 78.80 ± 3.91%), respectively. By contrast, E750 yielded the lowest postthaw velocity, viability, and total and progressive motility. Despite the increase in the motility parameters, fertilization in E350 (13.93%) was approximately double that in E500 (6.58%), although not statistically different. In conclusion, traditional isosmotic base extenders (E350) were found to be superior to hypertonic base extenders in the preservation of Sauger milt. These results serve as a starting point for future investigations of cryopreservation potential for Sauger spermatozoa that work toward developing a freezing protocol that is more suitable for large-scale application.