Income or Consumption: Which Better Predicts Subjective Well‐Being?

Abstract

The positive relationship between income and subjective well‐being has been well documented. However, work assessing the relationship of alternative material well‐being metrics to subjective well‐being (SWB) is limited. Consistent with the permanent income hypothesis, we find that a consumption‐based measure out‐performs (surveyed) income in predicting subjective well‐being. When objective measures of consumption are combined with self‐assessments of a household’s standard of living, income becomes insignificant altogether. We obtain our result utilizing household‐level data from Statistics New Zealand’s New Zealand General Social Survey which contains measures of income, SWB and a measure of material well‐being called the Economic Living Standard Index that combines measures of consumption flows and self‐assessments of material well‐being.

Measuring Economic Mobility in India Using Noisy Data: A Partial Identification Approach

“…Furthermore, the sample size of ARIS/REDS is much smaller; the …rst round of the ARIS/REDS covered 4,527 households across 259 villages and the latest round covered 9,500 households. 11…”

Self-perceptions and perceptions of peers: their role in understanding expenditure behaviours

“…The relationship between subjective and material well-being is of primary interest in the Economics of Happiness literature, with empirical investigations mainly focused on the effect of economic variables such as unemployment, inflation, income and consumption on happiness (Carver and Grimes 2019;Clark 2017Clark , 2018Diener et al 2015;DeLeire and Kalil 2010;Reyes-García et al 2019;Yeniaras et al 2016;Verme 2011).…”

“…Individual Expenditures and Subjective Well-being. Carver and Grimes (2019) depicted the dualism of income and consumption-based measures in defining material well-being. Despite the centenarian interest and the efforts of policy makers to improve classical measures of production and income, e.g.…”

Does urbanization matter in the expenditure‐happiness nexus?

“…The wealth prosperity of economies represents one of the main socio‐cultural and economic global goals of the last century. In particular, material and subjective well‐being (Carver & Grimes, 2019) are receiving growing attention from social scientists, as well as national and international organizations, with a strong interest in providing development plans and programs.…”