In surgeons performing cardiothoracic surgery is sleep deprivation significant in its impact on morbidity or mortality?

Abstract

A best evidence topic in cardiac surgery was written according to a structured protocol. The question addressed was: is there a difference in cardiothoracic surgery outcomes in terms of morbidity or mortality of patients operated on by a sleep-deprived surgeon compared with those operated by a non-sleep-deprived surgeon? Reported search criteria yielded 77 papers, of which 15 were deemed to represent the best evidence on the topic. Three studies directly related to cardiothoracic surgery and 12 studies related to non-cardiothoracic surgery. Recommendations are based on 18 121 cardiothoracic patients and 214 666 non-cardiothoracic surgical patients. Different definitions of sleep deprivation were used in the studies, either reviewing surgeon's sleeping hours or out-of-hours operating. Surgical outcomes reviewed included: mortality rate, neurological, renal, pulmonary, infectious complications, length of stay, length of intensive care stay, cardiopulmonary bypass times and aortic-cross-clamp times. There were no significant differences in mortality or intraoperative complications in the groups of patients operated on by sleep-deprived versus non-sleep-deprived surgeons in cardiothoracic studies. One study showed a significant increase in the rate of septicaemia in patients operated on by severely sleep-deprived surgeons (3.6%) compared with the moderately sleep-deprived (0.9%) and non-sleep-deprived groups (0.8%) (P = 0.03). In the non-cardiothoracic studies, 7 of the 12 studies demonstrated statistically significant higher reoperation rate in trauma cases (P<0.02) and kidney transplants (night = 16.8% vs day = 6.4%, P <0.01), as well as higher overall mortality (P = 0.028) and morbidity (P <0.0001). There is little direct evidence in the literature demonstrating the effect of sleep deprivation in cardiothoracic surgeons on morbidity or mortality. However, overall the non-cardiothoracic studies have demonstrated that operative time and sleep deprivation can have a significant impact on overall morbidity and mortality. It is likely that other confounding factors concomitantly affect outcomes in out-of-hours surgery.

Acute surgical unit improves outcomes in appendicectomy

“…After‐hours operating is known to carry a higher risk of surgical error and patient morbidity . Accordingly, a key aim when introducing an ASU has been to increase the proportion of in‐hours procedures.…”

The impact of sleep deprivation in military surgical teams: a systematic review

“…Among anaesthetic trainees, 63% reported their ability to perform professionally as ‘ low ’ after a night shift and a concerning 15% admitted to having a fatigue-related motor accident during his or her training programme 33. Procedures performed by cardiothoracic surgeons ‘ out-of-hours ’ between 21:00 and 05:00 and those ending between 23:00 and 07:30, resulted in a significantly higher rate of postoperative sepsis in patients 34. Asfour et al 34 concluded that sleep deprivation in out-of-hours non-cardiothoracic surgery, including trauma and general surgery had a significant impact on overall morbidity and mortality.…”

Does emergency general surgery model affect staff satisfaction, training and working hours?

“…The short-term deleterious effects of fatigue on safe performance are well recognized in surgery. 36,37 Additionally, long-term adverse effects of chronically disrupted sleep include obesity, diabetes mellitus, cardiovascular disease and cancer. 38 We found the average longest rostered duration on-duty which included weekdays reached or exceeded high-risk thresholds 39 for surgeons regardless of EGS model (means 59 versus 41 h), and for registrars working in traditional (mean 22 h) but not hybrid or ASU structures (mean 15 h).…”