Previous experiments on nanocrystalline Ni were conducted under quasistatic strain rates ͑ϳ3 ϫ 10 −3 /s͒, which are much lower than that used in typical molecular dynamics simulations ͑Ͼ3 ϫ 10 7 /s͒, thus making direct comparison of modeling and experiments very difficult. In this study, the split Hopkinson bar tests revealed that nanocrystalline Ni prefers twinning to extended partials, especially under higher strain rates ͑10 3 /s͒. These observations contradict some reported molecular dynamics simulation results, where only extended partials, but no twins, were observed. The accuracy of the generalized planar fault energies is only partially responsible, but cannot fully account for such a difference. © 2007 American Institute of Physics. ͓DOI: 10.1063/1.2745250͔To design nanocrystalline ͑nc͒ materials for superior mechanical properties, it is critical to understand their deformation physics.1 Face-centered-cubic ͑fcc͒ nc metals have been reported to deform by partial dislocation emission from grain boundaries ͑GBs͒, 2-10 full dislocation, 3,5,7 GB sliding,3,[11][12][13] grain rotation, 11,14 and deformation twinning. 2,3,[6][7][8][9][13][14][15][16][17][18][19][20] Significantly, recent molecular dynamics ͑MD͒ simulations ͑Ref. 5͒ as well as analytical models ͑Ref. 15͒ predicted that generalized planar fault energy ͑GPFE͒ curves play a critical role in the partial-dislocation-mediated slip in nc metals. Specifically, MD simulations predicted that nc Ni preferred to deform by extended partials despite its high stable stacking fault energy, and twinning was less favorable due to its very high unstable twin fault energy.5 These results countered the conventional beliefs in the scientific community and stimulated more experimental work. To experimentally assess these MD simulation results, we recently deformed nc Ni film with an average grain size of 25 nm under tension at liquid nitrogen temperature.20 Different than the MD prediction, both stacking faults and deformation twins were readily observed after deformation, with the density of twins higher than that of stacking faults. The observation of stacking faults agreed with the MD simulation prediction, however, the large number of twins contradicted it.One of the major differences in experiments and MD simulations is the strain rates: the experiments were conducted under a quasistatic strain rate ͑3 ϫ 10 −3 s −1 ͒, which is much lower than typical strain rates used in MD simulations ͑Ͼ10 7 s −1 ͒.3 Although high strain rates had been found to promote twinning in coarse-grained metals, 9,21 the huge difference in strain rates still raises an issue on the adequacy of the experimental results in validating MD simulation results. Therefore, it would be of interest to deform the nc Ni at a high strain rate and compare its deformation physics with that observed under the low strain rate and with MD simulation results. Another issue is the accuracy of the atomic potential used in MD simulations, which was found to significantly affect GPFE curves. 22 Recently, a mo...