In Search of the Pitiful Victim: A Frame Analysis of Dutch, Flemish and British Newspapers and NGO‐Advertisements

Abstract

This article contributes to the ongoing debate on the representation of global poverty in Western media. Both NGOs and journalists are being criticized for their one‐sided emphasis on the misery and dependency of people in developing countries. The objective of this paper is to measure the extent of such problematizing representation in newspaper articles and NGO‐advertisements. A frame analysis was conducted of 876 articles and 284 advertisements from the Netherlands, Flanders and the United Kingdom. The results challenge some conventional assumptions. Overall, the ‘victim frame’ and ‘pitiful images’ do not dominate the discourse of NGOs and newspapers. However, British NGOs are an exception: they portray the poor as ‘pitiful victims’ twice as often as their counterparts in the Netherlands and Flanders. Furthermore, the findings confirm the conviction that the media predominantly highlight poor countries' dependence on the West. Copyright © 2016 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Anticipating public expectations of humanitarian action—An ethnographic study of recruiting donors through face‐to‐face fundraising

“…The specific quotes in Section 4 exemplify these general conditions. However, our findings on the factors influencing the discursive content of face‐to‐face fundraising warrant caution regarding their generalisability beyond the Finnish context because, as Vossen, Van Gorp, and Schulpen () have shown, the discursive tactics of fundraising are country specific.…”

“…The specific quotes in Section 4 exemplify these general conditions. However, our findings on the factors influencing the discursive content of face-to-face fundraising warrant caution regarding their generalisability beyond the Finnish context because, as Vossen, Van Gorp, and Schulpen (2016) Designing a fundraising campaign begins with selecting the projects and activities that have the highest potential to interest audiences. Our informants revealed that sometimes public opinions about humanitarian action are studied through commissioned research.…”

Neutral press, negative opinions: development cooperation and the Dutch media

“…The initial inductive frame analysis revealed nine frames, which were labelled "victim", "progress", "social justice", "chain of being", "every man for himself", "blame us", "bad governance", "impending doom" and "global village". Previous investigation into the framing of global poverty in the European media has shown that six frames play a role in the media coverage (Vossen, Van Gorp and Schulpen 2016). The frequency of six frames was measured in a deductive analysis.…”

Poverty in the news media: Continuities, ruptures, and change in the reporting socioeconomic inequality

“…For example, sociology and political science have looked at a variety of aspects that shape the reporting of news on poverty. This includes examining how issues such as how media campaigns and lobbies from anti‐poverty NGOs and think‐tanks are shaping the news agenda (Bendell, ; Nash, ; Rich & Weaver, ; Seo, Kim, & Yang, ; Vossen, Van Gorp, & Schulpen, ; Waisbord, ; Wright, ) to studying how news on poverty frames the public's perception on health policy (Briggs & Hallin, ; Hinnant, Subramanian, & Jenkins, ; Waisbord, ) and includes areas such as how architecture and urban studies have researched in their own field poverty in the news (Lee et al, ; Petty, ).…”