Improving the quality of vocational students’ collaboration and knowledge acquisition through instruction and joint reflection

Abstract

New societal demands call for schools to train students' collaboration skills. However, research thus far has focused mainly on promoting collaboration to facilitate knowledge acquisition and has rarely provided insight into how to train students' collaboration skills. This study demonstrates the positive effects on the quality of students' collaboration and their knowledge acquisition of an instructional approach that consists of conventional instruction and an online tool that fosters students' joint reflection on their collaborative behavior by employing self-and peer assessment and goal setting. Both the instruction and the collaboration reflection tool were designed to promote students' awareness of effective collaboration characteristics (the RIDE rules) and their own collaborative behavior. First-year technical vocational students (N = 198, M age = 17.7 years) worked in heterogeneous triads in a computer-supported collaborative learning environment (CSCL) on topics concerning electricity. They received either 1) conventional instruction about collaboration and the online collaboration reflection tool, 2) collaboration instruction only, or 3) no collaboration instruction and no tool. Analysis of chat data (n = 92) and knowledge tests (n = 87) showed that students from the instruction with tool condition outperformed the other students as far as their collaborative behavior and their domain knowledge gains.

Does the Development Economics Learning Design Need to Be Redesigned?

“…This is in line with research conducted by Brindley, Walti, & Blaschke that at the time of collaboration, students share their knowledge so that they obtain richer knowledge through joint exploration and the achievement of shared meanings [47]. Other research results also show that collaborative activities make students more involved in the learning process so that it leads to increased mastery of concepts [48], [49].…”

The impact of functional interdependencies of computer simulations on collaborative learning: Evidence from multiple sources

“…The aim of computer simulation in computer supported collaborative learning (CSCL) studies is to scaffold collaborative learning process on a contextualized environment that helps students achieve deeper understanding through shared problematizing (Pietarinen et al, 2021). The study conducted by Eshuis et al (2019) prompted students to learn with computer simulations and guided them to reflect upon the collaboration activities to acquire both science knowledge and collaboration skills. A new form of computer simulations, collaborative simulations, are available on some online platforms, which support students at distributed locations to synchronously collaborate on the simulations to learn sciences.…”

Moving towards engaged learning in STEM domains; there is no simple answer, but clearly a road ahead

“…In a recent study, however, Chang et al () found that not all collaborative groups learning with an online simulation were able to engage in a productive collaboration process; obviously, collaboration between students also needs to be trained or supported. In a recent study on learning with a simulation of energy transport systems, Eshuis et al (in press) compared students who received instruction about collaboration with students who received this instruction plus a tool that visualized their own assessment of the collaboration process and that prompted them to reflect on their collaboration. These authors found that the latter group outperformed the first on a number of central collaboration processes and on a resulting knowledge test.…”