Improving students' inquiry learning in web‐based environments by providing structure: Does the teacher matter or platform matter?

Abstract

Web‐based scientific inquiry learning is characterized as providing an autonomy‐supportive environment for students to solve scientific problems. However, as a complementary approach for improving students' learning, structure‐supportive strategies in a web‐based learning environment deserve further exploration. Whilst both teachers and platforms could make essential contributions in providing structure support, research findings concerning how teachers could successfully interact with the platform in such an environment are scarce. Grounded on self‐determination theory, two quasi‐experimental studies with pre and post measurements were conducted to address two questions. First, whether structure support could improve students' inquiry learning in an autonomous web‐based inquiry learning environment? Second, what is the relationship between teachers and platforms in doing this? As hypothesized, study 1 provides empirical evidence on the effectiveness of applying structure‐supportive instructional strategies in autonomous web‐based scientific inquiry. Study 2 confirmed that students performed best in the class with high structure support provided by both teachers and platforms. The results shed light on the positive impacts of integrating both autonomy and structure support and emphasize the critical role of teachers in a web‐based inquiry learning environment. Additionally, they infer a possible causal link between the efficient application of structure strategies and students' learning outcomes. What is already known about this topic A web‐based scientific inquiry learning environment is helpful in assisting science inquiry learning. However, appropriate scaffolding is critical for students in regulating their learning. The autonomy‐ and structure‐supportive strategies could positively influence students' academic performance in the traditional face‐to‐face environment. However, how to integrate both strategies in web‐based learning environments deserves more exploration. Both teachers and platforms should make important contributions in providing structure support, but empirical evidence on how to integrate both are highly needed. What this paper adds The findings of the current study contribute to the growing body of literature by highlighting the potential importance of self‐determination theory (SDT) in designing instructional strategies from an integrated perspective, particularly in a web‐based scientific learning environment. The results shed light on the positive impacts of integrating both autonomy and structure support, but also provide more implications inferring a possible causal link between the efficient application of structure strategies and students' learning outcomes. The results further indicated the essential role of teachers in a web‐based inquiry science environment. Implications for practice and/or policy As we recognize the significance of autonomy‐supportive web‐based learning environments, its weaknesses should not be ignored. In designing such a platform, appropriate str...

Exploring the multidimensional relationships between educational situation perception, teacher support, online learning engagement, and academic self-efficacy in technology-based language learning

“…On the theoretical level, the conception of situation perception holds that knowledge is an interactive state constructed in the process of the interaction between individuals and the environment, contends that learning is the construction of individual meaning completed in authentic situations and practical activities, and meanwhile emphasizes the influence mechanism of the creation of educational situations on the cognitive development of learners (Chu et al, 2010;Healey et al, 2010;Hwang and Chang, 2011). In recent years, in the field of learning science, the study of the influence mechanism of media, resources, environments, learning behaviors and other factors on learners' cognitive and emotional development also confirmed the complex functional relationship between "situation" and the learning occurrence mechanism of learners (Hung et al, 2013;Martin and Ertzberger, 2013;He and Li, 2019;Cui et al, 2022). This category of study accords with the notion of learning ecology put forward by Barron (2004), who defined as "the accessed set of contexts, comprised of configurations of activities, material resources and relationships, found in co-located physical or virtual spaces that provide opportunities for learning" (p. 6).…”

“…Self-determination theory put forward by Deci and Ryan (2000) concentrates largely on how the environments affect people’s basic psychological needs for autonomy, competence, and relatedness ( Jeno et al, 2019 ), which can be used to comprehend the enhancement of learners’ online learning engagement through the effects exerted by the educational environments ( Chiu, 2021 ). Besides, responding to the network ecological environment, scholars have conducted the ecological exploration of language teaching, such as focusing on the discourse analysis of teacher-student interaction and peer interaction ( Gawande and Al-Senaidi, 2015 ), the online interactive network structure characteristics of adult learners in the network environment ( Sabah, 2016 ), and the construction and implementation path of personalized intelligent teaching model ( Cui et al, 2022 ), and so on. However, the existing studies rarely discuss the influence of teacher support and educational situation on the online learning engagement and its influence mechanisms.…”

Knowledge Integration in Science Learning: Tracking Students' Knowledge Development and Skill Acquisition with Cognitive Diagnosis Models

“…The analyses drew on the evaluation rubric in Cui et al. (2022) for scoring these items. Specifically, all the blank‐filling questions were dichotomous items scored 0 (incorrect) or 1 (correct).…”

“…In the current study, a WISE project titled Thermal Challenge was adopted. The corresponding Chinese version was adapted by Cui et al (2022) (http://wise.bnu.edu.cn/). The main question of this project was "Can we use the same material to design a Thermos cup for hot or cold drinks?"…”

Learning behavior, digital platforms for learning and its impact on university student’s motivations and knowledge development

“… Aduba and Mayowa-Adebara’s (2022) study examines how internet platforms were used during the lockdown and ( Luo et al, 2019 ) interpersonal connections have a good influence on the learners’ experience, strengthening their desire to utilize the e-learning platform. Cui et al (2022) highlight the benefits of combining autonomy with structural assistance and the importance of instructors in a web-based inquiry learning environment. Kang and Zhang (2020) suggest that online education is becoming more popular globally because it engages and motivates students.…”