Improving on Defaults: Helping Pension Participants Manage Financial Market Risk in Target Date Funds

Abstract

The central issue of this paper is analysis and resulting proposals to help unsophisticated pension participants achieve pension portfolios that match their level of risk aversion when there is a large amount of unexplained heterogeneity in risk aversion. Target date funds are commonly used as the default investment in defined contribution plans in the U.S., UK and other countries. These funds recognize that individuals usually should hold less risky investment portfolios as their expected retirement date approaches because their ability to bear financial market risk declines as the time horizon decreases. However, these funds do not account for differences in risk aversion among people with the same target date. Empirical studies find large amounts of unexplained heterogeneity in risk aversion. Target date funds cannot deal with this issue simply by sorting people into demographic groupings, other than age, that are known to affect risk aversion, such as gender. Financial education can help people do a better job of managing financial market risk in their pension portfolios, but we argue that it is unreasonable to expect millions of pension participants to attain advanced levels of financial literacy. This paper considers three innovations in target date funds that can help individual pension participants do a better job of managing financial market risk. The analysis can be applied to other situations where defaults are used for investing pension participants’ portfolios. The paper suggests new lines of research relating to individual differences in risk aversion.

Strategies in Retirement Fund Selection in the Mexican Retirement Market 1997-2018

“…The suggestion of a personalization in the market of retirement funds is also present in the research of Turner and Klein (2021). They study retirement target date funds and argue that they do not account for differences in individual risk aversion within the target date group and that to attain the level of financial education needed to manage a well-diversified portfolio for millions of people is an unrealistic task.…”