Improving newborn heart rate assessment using a simple visual timer

Abstract

ObjectiveNewborn resuscitation relies on accurate heart rate (HR) assessment, which, during auscultation, is prone to error. We investigated if a 6 s visual timer (VT) could improve HR assessment accuracy during newborn simulation.DesignProspective observational study of newborn healthcare professionals.SettingThree-phase developmental approach: phase I: HR auscultation during newborn simulation using a standard clock timer (CT) or the VT; phase II: repeat phase I after using a bespoke training app (NeoRate); phase III: following the Newborn Life Support course, participants assessed random HRs using the CT or VT.Main outcome measuresHR accuracy (within ±10 beats/min, correct HR category, i.e. <60, 60–100 and >100 beats/min), assessment time and error-free rates were compared.ResultsOverall, 1974 HR assessments were performed with participants more accurate using the VT for ±10 beats/min (70% CT vs 86% VT, p<0.001) and correct HR category (78% CT vs 84% VT, p<0.01). The VT improved accuracy across all three phases. Additionally, following app training in phase II, the HR accuracy of both the CT and VT improved. The VT resulted in faster HR assessment times of 11 s (IQR 9–13) compared with the CT at 15 s (IQR 9–23, p<0.001). Error-free scenarios increased from 24% using the CT to 57% using the VT (p<0.001), with a shorter assessment time (CT 116 s (IQR 65–156) vs VT 53 s (IQR 50–64), p<0.001).ConclusionUsing a VT to assess simulated newborn HR combined with a training app significantly improves accuracy and reduces assessment time compared with standard methods. Evaluation in the clinical setting is required to determine potential benefits.

Parental Ability to Assess Pediatric Vital Signs

“…Previously, NeoTap, a smartphone application, was shown to have improved the accuracy of heart rate auscultation of newborn infants in health care settings. 14,25,26 In the present study, smartphone applications based on photoplethysmography did not improve the accuracy of parental heart rate measurements. The poor accuracy of parental measurements with two contact photoplethysmography smartphone applications was unexpected because, in adults, heart rate measurements with mobile apps have been shown to correlate well with the ECG.…”