Impounded Marshes on Subsided Islands: Simulated Vertical Accretion, Processes, and Effects, Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta, CA USA

Abstract

There is substantial interest in stopping and reversing the effects of subsidence in the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta (Delta) where organic soils predominate. Also, the passage of California Assembly Bill 32 in 2006 created the potential to trade credits for carbon sequestered in wetlands on subsided Delta islands. The primary purpose of the work described here was to estimate future vertical accretion and understand processes that affect vertical accretion and carbon sequestration in impounded marshes on subsided Delta islands. Using a cohort-accounting model, we simulated vertical accretion from 4,700 calibrated years before present (BP) at a wetland area located within Franks Tract State Recreation Area (lat 38.059, long −121.611, hereafter, "Franks Wetland")-a small, relatively undisturbed marsh island-and at the Twitchell Island subsidencereversal demonstration project since 1997. We used physical and chemical data collected during the study as well as literature values for model inputs. Model results compared favorably with measured rates of vertical accretion, mass of carbon sequestered, bulk density and organic matter content.From 4,700 to model-estimated 350 years BP, the simulated rate of vertical accretion at Franks Wetland averaged about 0.12 cm yr -1 , which is within the range of rates in tidal wetlands worldwide. Our model results indicate that large sediment inputs during the last 150 to 200 years resulted in a higher accretion rate of 0.3 cm yr -1 . On Twitchell Island, greater organic inputs resulted in average vertical accretion rates as high as 9.2 cm yr -1 . Future simulations indicate that the managed impounded marsh will accrete highly organic material at rates of about 3 cm yr -1 . Model results coupled with GIS analysis indicate that large areas of the periphery of the Delta, if impounded and converted to freshwater marsh, could be restored to tidal elevations within 50 to 100 years. Most of the central Delta would require 50 to 250 years to be restored to projected mean sea level. A large portion of the western Delta could be restored to mean sea level within 50 to 150 years (large areas on Sherman, Jersey, and Bethel islands, and small areas on Bradford, Twitchell, and Brannan islands, and Webb Tract). We estimated that long-term carbon sequestration rates for impounded marshes such as the Twitchell Island demonstration ponds will range from 12 to 15 metric tons carbon ha -1 yr -1 . Creation of impounded marshes on Delta islands can substantially benefit levee stability as demonstrated by cumulative force and hydraulic gradient calculations.1 HydroFocus, Inc., Davis, CA USA 2 U.S. Geological Survey, California Water Science Center Sacramento, CA USA * Corresponding author: sdeverel@hydrofocus.com SAN FRANCISCO ESTUARY & WATERSHED SCIENCE 2 INTRODUCTIONThe 300,000-ha Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta is a critical natural resource, important agricultural region and the hub for California's water supply. Within an area of about 81,000 ha in the central Delta, an estimated 4.5 billion ...

A Biogeochemical Compromise: The High Methane Cost of Sequestering Carbon in Restored Wetlands

“…Delta wetlands sequestered C at rates of up to 698 g C · m À2 · year À1 and accreted~3 cm of new peat per year (Deverel et al, 2014). However, building peat soil through uptake of CO 2 in these highly productive ecosystems comes at a steep CH 4 cost (Table 1).…”

Implications for Greenhouse Gas Emission Reductions and Economics of a Changing Agricultural Mosaic in the Sacramento–San Joaquin Delta

“…Constructing wetlands and cultivating rice on southern Staten will provide substantial levee benefit over the long term because of the beneficial effects on seepage and subsidence, where vulnerability is the highest. As groundwater levels rise under wetlands and rice, seepage forces (as determined by calculation of exit gradients), which can threaten levee stability, will decrease (e.g., Deverel et al 2014). …”

The degree of peatland subsidence resulting from drainage of land

“…In the Everglades, USA, an average long-term subsidence rate of 3 cm year -1 was reported after the initial years (Stephens et al 1984), but this was for a different peat type in a sub-tropical region with a lower surface peat temperature of 25°C. In peatland with an initial organic content of around 80% in the Sacramento Delta, California, subsidence after the initial 5 years proceeded at a constant rate of 7.5 cm year -1 for over 50 years (Deverel et al 2014).…”