Importance Performance Analysis of Factors Causing Reworks in the Construction Industry

Abstract

Rework can bring negative effect to construction project. This research aims to identify the importance level of factors causing reworks in structural, finishing, and mechanical, electrical and plumbing (MEP) works by a way of importance performance analysis (IPA). In order to reach this objective, the research evaluates the degree of occurrence the factors in each type of works and analyzes the level of difficulty in preventing the occurrence of the factors. The results are based on questionnaire survey, involving general and MEP contractors in Surabaya. Design related factors are the most frequent and most difficult to prevent in structural and finishing works. In MEP works, the most frequent factors are tight construction duration and unclear instructions from owner and designer; whilst insufficient owner’s capital is the most difficult to prevent. The research finds two factors that have high importance level, i.e. design changes and insufficient detail drawings.

Analisis Critical Success Factor Kinerja Proyek Preservasi Jalan Nasional dengan Skema Long Segment: Pelaksanaan di Provinsi Sumatera Utara

“…Critical Success Factor yang signifikan berpengaruh terhadap keberhasilan proyek, yang pertama adalah faktor tenaga kerja (X1). Hasil ini sesuai dengan penelitian terdahulu yang mengidentifikasi kedisiplinan dan ketersediaan tenaga kerja signifikan mempengaruhi keberhasilan proyek (Andi, Susandi, & Wijaya, 2003). (Dai, Goodrum, & Maloney, 2007) juga telah mengidentifikasi faktor ini dalam bentuk tingkat motivasi pekerja.…”

“…Hal tersebut sesuai dengan penelitian yang dilakukan oleh (Silaen et al, 2020) dimana standar uji mutu memberikan kontribusi probabilitas keberhasilan proyek sebesar 81.6%. (Andi et al, 2003) juga mengidentifikasi kontrol mutu berpengaruh terhadap keberhasilan proyek.…”

Analisis Keterlambatan Proyek Pada Pembangunan Tanggul Pengaman Pantai Di Jakarta

“…Menurut Andi et al (2003), secara umum faktor-faktor penyebab keterlambatan yang dapat mempengaruhi waktu penyelesaian konstruksi terdiri dari tujuh kategori, yaitu tenaga kerja, bahan, peralatan, karakteristik tempat, manajerial, keuangan dan faktor-faktor lainnya seperti intensitas hujan, kecelakaan kerja dan kondisi ekonomi.…”

Analysis of the Influence of Internal Factors on Project Performance in Low-Rise Commercial Building Construction Projects in Tangerang

“…Construction can be defined as the arrangement of the elements of a building (Rani, 2023). According to Andi et al (2003), In general, the potential factors that affect construction time consist of seven categories, namely labor, materials/materials, equipment, site characteristics, managerial, financial, other factors. According to Proboyo (1999), in general, project delays often occur due to changes in planning during the implementation process, poor management in the contractor's organization, work plans that are not well arranged / integrated, incomplete drawings and specifications, or the contractor's failure to carry out the work.…”