Impoliteness and Gender Differences in the Edge of Seventeen Movie

Abstract

This paper aims to analyze the impoliteness strategies performed by the main female character (Nadine) and her male interlocutors in the Edge of Seventeen movie. Taking Nadine’s impolite utterances and her male interlocutors as the data, this study found a thought-provoking fact that women who have been stereotyped as “powerless” language users also have the potential to use impoliteness strategies as a way of negotiating and constructing their identity. While both genders could use impoliteness strategies to negotiate and construct their power and identity in interactions, there were differences in the use of the strategies. Women prefer to use positive impoliteness while men use negative impoliteness strategies. The use of positive impoliteness among women is influenced by their empathetic nature to social relations. Any sensitive topic to social relations is considered effective as a face-threatening act. On the other hand, men use negative impoliteness to force their interlocutors to submit to their will, a trait of male dominance. By suppressing the freedom of choice of the interlocutor, the negative face is threatened. From these findings, it can be concluded that impoliteness can be used, by men and women, as a tool to exercise their power and construct their gender identity.

How Polite can Impoliteness be? A Jordanian Gendered Perspective

“…Like politeness (Chambers, 1992;Holmes, 1995;Lakoff, 1975;Mills, 2003;Trudgill, 1972), impoliteness is affected by gender (e.g., Suhandoko et al, 2021), as gender constitutes a catalyst for building both personality and social relationships. According to Eckert and McConnell-Ginet (2003),…”

Politeness Strategies Employed in Communication with Santri and Ustadz in an Islamic Boarding School in Indonesia

“…Differences in age, degree of social level, and distance of intimacy between the speaker and the interlocutor will determine the variation of the language chosen. When speaking, errors in the selection of language variations will lead to irregularities and are considered impolite [33]. There are three levels of language use in Javanese, namely Ngoko, Krama Madya, and Krama Inggil.…”

Expressive Acts Constructing Religious Identity among Indonesian Muslim Influencers on Instagram

“…Furthermore, a number of previous studies also investigated identity construction (Alivin, 2021;Fatmawati, 2015;Hidayah & Milal, 2016;Suhandoko et al, 2021). Alivin (2021) focused on identity negotiation experienced by Muslim diaspora characters by employing Homi K. Bhabha's cultural identity.…”

“…Fatmawati (2015) identified the novel The Zahir utterances, which contains the use of label and stance-taking, which reveals the character's identity. Suhandoko et al (2021) explained how gender identity was constructed in the Edge of Seventeen movie by investigating how different genders used impolite words.…”