Implementing Portfolios in Teacher Training:Why we use them and why we should use them

Abstract

Problem statement: After the implementation of new curricula in 2005, portfolios have become commonplace in teacher training programs in Turkey. Even though the use of portfolios is quite popular, the studies have shown that portfolios are mostly used to assess student learning outcomes, while the effectiveness of the educators and teacher training programs is usually unnoticed. For this reason, this study will focus on the contributions of portfolio utilization to educators and training programs. Purpose of Study:This study investigates the use of the portfolios in teacher training programs and analyses the contribution of portfolio utilization to educators, teacher training programs, and students.Method: An action research design was adopted involving 25 third grade social studies student teachers, who were randomly chosen from a sample of 128 students by selecting every fifth student on the classroom list of a semester-long course (14 weeks) in the 2012-2013 academic years at a state university in Turkey. This is a qualitative research study based on four open-ended questions and semi-structured interviews that were conducted with eight educators. Findings and Results:The findings indicated that portfolio utilization helps educators make modifications in their traditional roles and encourages them to adopt more student-centred approaches. In addition, portfolios assist in clarifying the program scope and goals and makes learning outcomes transparent. Furthermore, portfolios are a viable, effective, and * Assist.Prof. Dr., Pamukkale University, Art and Science Faculty, aksitf@pau.edu.tr 98Fisun Aksit appropriate tool in documenting student teachers' learning and professional development. Conclusions and Recommendations:The results of the research show that educators should take the utilization of portfolio into account not just to increase students' learning and assessment but also because of its additional benefits to educators and programs through many factors, such as being informed about the qualities and effectiveness of the program and daily lectures, putting the constructivist philosophy of the program into practice, creating a more democratic environment, ensuring one-toone interaction with the students, providing individualized learning, and using assessment as an integral part of learning and promoting dialogue with colleagues.

Öğretmen Adaylarının Öğrenci Ürün Dosyası Uygulamasına İlişkin Görüşleri

“…The implementation of portfolio in education has gained great momentum in recent years. Looked at the relevant literature, it is seen that in addition to studies about portfolio with regard to different stakeholders' opinions (Akdağ, Çinici, & Akgün, 2014;Aksit, 2016;Aydın, 2010;Bedir, Polat, & Sakacı, 2009;Coşkun, 2011;Deveci, Ersoy, & Ersoy, 2006;Gezer , 2012;Kayri, 2013), there were studies about portfolio with regard to academic achievement (Bahçeci & Kuru, 2006;Birgin 2011;Köroğlu, Mutlu, 2011;) and the effects of portfolio on students' attitude towards different courses (Gülbahar & Köse, 2006;Korkmaz & Kaptan, 2003;Bedir, Polat, & Sakacı, 2009). The aim of this study is to determine teacher candidates' opinions on the portfolio implementation process.…”

“…Öğrenci ürün dosyasının eğitimde uygulanması son yıllarda büyük ivme kazanmıştır. İlgili alan yazına bakıldığında, öğrenci ürün dosyasına ilişkin görüşler (Akdağ, Çinici ve Akgün, 2014;Aksit, 2016;Aydın, 2010;Bedir, Polat ve Sakacı, 2009;Coşkun, 2011;Deveci, Ersoy ve Ersoy, 2006;Gezer, 2012;Kayri, 2013) alınmakla beraber, öğrenci ürün dosyasının akademik başarı (Bahçeci ve Kuru, 2006;Birgin 2011¸ Köroğlu, Mutlu, 2011 ve öğrenci ürün dosyasının öğrencilerin derse yönelik tutumuna etkisine ilişkin çalışmaların (Bedir, Polat ve Sakacı, 2009;Gülbahar ve Köse, 2006;Korkmaz ve Kaptan, 2003) yapıldığı görülmektedir.…”

“…Günümüzde birçok eğitimci, öğrenci ürün dosyalarını kullanmaktadır ve bunlara ilişkin çalışmalar yapmaktadır ancak bu çalışmaların çoğu öğrenci ürün dosyalarını nasıl kullanıldığını, neden kullanıldıklarını ve nasıl oluşturulduğu açıklayan teorik bilgiler sunan çalışmalardır (Beard, 2015;Horton, 2004;Hubball ve Robertson, 2004;Melograno, 2000;Napper-Owen, 1997). Öğrenci ürün dosyalarının mevcut popülaritesine rağmen bunların uygulamada etkili olma durumuna ve katkısına yönelik istenilen şekilde çok fazla araştırma bulunmamaktadır (Aksit, 2016;Anderson ve De Meulle, 1998;Author ve Harting, 2013). Bu nedenle eğitim alanında uygulamaya konan öğrenci ürün dosyalarına ilişkin öğretmen adaylarının görüşlerinin araştırılmasına gereksinim duyulmaktadır.…”

Paper-based Portfolio as an Educational Tool: Nursing Students' Perspective

“…The students learn to take responsibility as a part of their developmental process because portfolio requires self-discipline with deadlines for submitting assignments (Buranz, 2011). Moreover, the teachers gain more detailed feedback about their teaching methods, techniques, and classroom management (Aksit, 2016). Through portfolio, teachers can observe students in a more realistic and detailed way and make more accurate decisions about them (Quansah, 2018).…”