Implementing Blended Care to Discontinue Benzodiazepine Receptor Agonist Use for Insomnia: Process Evaluation of a Pragmatic Cluster Randomized Controlled Trial

Abstract

Background Long-term use of benzodiazepine receptor agonists (BZRAs) remains common despite European guidelines advising that these drugs be used in the lowest possible dose and for the shortest possible duration. Half of all BZRAs are prescribed in family practice. This creates a window of opportunity for discontinuation in primary care. Therefore, the effectiveness of blended care for the discontinuation of long-term BZRA use in adult primary care patients with chronic insomnia disorder was tested in a multicenter, pragmatic, and cluster randomized controlled superiority trial in Belgium. In the literature, information on implementing blended care in a primary care setting is scarce. Objective The study aimed to contribute to a framework for the successful implementation of blended care in a primary care setting by increasing our understanding of this complex intervention through an evaluation of e-tool use and views and ideas of participants in a BZRA discontinuation trial. Methods Based on a theoretical framework, this study evaluated the processes of recruitment, delivery, and response using 4 components: a survey on recruitment (n=76), semistructured in-depth interviews with patients (n=18), web-based asynchronous focus groups with general practitioners (GPs; n=19), and usage data of the web-based tool. Quantitative data were analyzed descriptively, and qualitative data were analyzed thematically. Results For recruitment, the most common barriers were refusal by the patient and the lack of digital literacy, while facilitators were starting the conversation and the curiosity of patients. The delivery of the intervention to the patients was diverse, ranging from GPs who never informed the patient about their access to the e-tool to GPs consulting the e-tool in between consultations to have discussion points when the patient visited. Concerning response, patients’ and GPs’ narratives also showed much variety. For some GPs, daily practice changed because they received more positive reactions than expected and felt empowered to talk more often about BZRA discontinuation. Conversely, some GPs reported no changes in practice or among patients. In general, patients found follow-up by an expert to be the most important component in blended care, whereas GPs deemed the intrinsic motivation of patients to be the key element of success. An important barrier to implementation by the GP was time. Conclusions Overall, the participants who had used the e-tool were positive about its structure and content. Nevertheless, many patients desired a more tailored application with feedback from an expert and personal tapering schedules. Strict pragmatic implementation of blended care seems to only reach GPs with an interest in digitalization. Although not superior to usual care, blended care could be a complementary tool that allows tailoring the discontinuation process to the personal style of the GP and the needs of the patient. Trial Registration ClinicalTrials.gov NCT03937180; https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT03937180

Information and Communication Technology-Based Application for Cognitive Behavioral Therapy among Community-Dwelling Older Adults with Insomnia: Development and Validation Study

“…Sleep diaries are essential resources that provide useful evaluation information and guide the completion of CBT strategies [ 41 ]. Sleep activities and patterns were assessed using a sleep diary, and the appropriate sleep duration was fed back to the participants.…”

“At the time I only wanted to relieve stress”: Exploring motivation for behaviour change in long-term hypnotic users

“…Although the study sample of the cluster randomised controlled trial ( Figure A2 ) had similar baseline characteristics – being sex, age and depression rates - to Belgian patients that receive three or more prescriptions for BZRA per year [ 46 ], participants may have been more motivated to reduce their BZRA intake than non-participating patients. Furthermore, some sampling bias occurred in the pragmatic trial as general practitioners confirmed that not all eligible patients had been invited due to their expectation of refusal [ 47 ]. Also, for the current paper, data were collected via telephone or video call due to COVID-19, which could have been a barrier for certain patients to participate.…”

Long-term use of benzodiazepines in chronic insomnia: a European perspective

“…Evidence has shown that in both short- and long-term scenarios, deprescribing BZDs by gradual tapering in combination with non-pharmacological support is more likely to succeed than gradual tapering alone ( 134 ). A multicenter, randomized interventional study in Belgium recently looked at strategies to support BZD discontinuation in primary care ( 135 ). This study found that the use of blended care, which combines the use of an interactive educational e-tool with face-to-face clinical consultations with the care provider, provides a complementary tool that enables the BZD discontinuation process to be tailored to the personal style of the GP and the needs of the patient.…”