Implementation of the CIPP evaluation model in Indonesian nursing schools

Abstract

Introduction: The implementation of the Indonesian National Nursing Competency Test (INNCT) has faced several challenges, especially related to the low pass rate. The pass rate has decreased over time, but the number of examinees has increased. The aim of this study was to evaluate the nursing schools’ performance in INNCT using the Context Input Process Product (CIPP) evaluation model.Methods: A quantitative description was used in this study. The Performance Evaluation of Nursing Program Questionnaire based on CIPP was developed and used to collect the data. The participants in this study were faculty members and alumni from the nursing schools that were a member of AINEC within region V. The variables of this study were the nursing school pass rate and the school’s performance.Results: 320 participants were involved in this study. The passing rate of the nursing school in INNCT was in the moderate category. The CIPP evaluation shows that out of the four aspects, there were two (2) aspects, namely “context and input” that were in the category of having met the requirements and two (2) aspects, namely “process and product”, were in the category exceeding the requirements.Conclusion: Nursing schools have fulfilled the government regulation based on the CIPP evaluation and the nursing schools need to make a strategic plan to improve their performance and to increase their pass rate in INNCT.

Perception of stakeholders on current perfusion education in Malaysia

“…The example of exit exam set by the American Board of Cardiovascular Perfusion are basic science and clinical science exams as many employers and some state licensure applications requirement (Riley et al, 2006). This is also supported by previous study conducted among nurses in Indonesian nursing institutions where the quality of a nursing education program is evidenced by the performance of its graduates on the licensure examination, hence exit exam is needed (Siswadi, 2019). Therefore, the exit exam is crucial to determine students' progress from didactic to the clinical phase and every student must pass the competency exit exam to obtain entry to the clinical employment (Riley et al, 2006).…”

“…As emphasized by the American Academy of Cardiovascular Perfusion, one of the qualities for an effective Perfusion Education Program is the requirement of institution and syllabus to be structured and certified and provide skilled instructors to continue education in improving knowledge and skill. The importance of having similar and comprehensive syllabus is also supported by previous study conducted in Indonesia among nurses revealed that there were disparity of nurses passing rate at 56.5% due to unstandardized syllabus (Siswadi et al, 2019). These can be due to the variety of learning and in the education standard for every nursing programme.…”

Evaluation of online learning in Natural Science for junior high school

“…On this occasion, the evaluation was focused on five aspects, namely: context (context), preparation (input), process (process), outcome (product), and impact (impact). According to Siswadi et al (2019), this evaluation model framework is more comprehensive to guide planning, implementation, and assessment, especially in learning programs. This evaluation research was conducted from April to May 2020.…”

Excellent Accreditation Design in High School

“…This study shows the novelty of the review of the accreditation model with 9 criteria, the majority of which previous research only used 7 criteria carried out at one of the universities in Java, namely Bina Bangsa University, which had not previously been accredited by BAN-PT. Previous studies assessed the quality and benefits of higher education programs (Lopez et al, 2011;Lippe & Carter, 2018;Finney, 2019;Siswadi, Houghty, & Agustina, 2020). However, these studies were not carried out at universities that have not been accredited as in this study.…”