Impaired Comprehension of Affective Prosody in Elderly Subjects Is Not Predicted by Age-Related Hearing Loss or Age-Related Cognitive Decline

Abstract

Impairments in the ability of elderly people to comprehend affective prosody have been reported, but little is known about the relationship between affective prosodic comprehension and age-related changes in hearing and cognition. The Aprosodia Battery, which included an assessment of attitudinal comprehension, was used to compare affective-prosodic comprehension in young and elderly subjects and to investigate the relationship of results to selected hearing and neuropsychological measures. As a group, the healthy elderly subjects were impaired relative to young subjects on all tasks assessing comprehension of affective prosody. Variability within the elderly group was not predicted by mild to moderate peripheral hearing loss and was only marginally predicted by traditional cognitive measures. These findings along with those of other researchers suggest that loss of affective-prosodic comprehension in elderly persons is related to a specific aging effect that impairs right hemisphere function.

Do Hearing Aids Improve Affect Perception?

“…Findings concerning the link between individual hearing loss and affect perception have been inconsistent. Orbelo and colleagues (Orbelo et al 2005) found no effect of hearing sensitivity on affect perception, while Rigo and Lieberman (Rigo and Lieberman 1989) found that low-frequency hearing loss (PTA low (0.25, 0.5, 1 kHz) > 25 dB HL) impacted affect perception. Note that both these studies used acted speech.…”

Emotion recognition in music changes across the adult life span

“…General cognitive decline would be yet another mechanism for age-related effects in emotion recognition, but it is one that has received little support (e.g., Mitchell, 2007;Orbelo, Grim, Talbott, & Ross, 2005). It predicts a more pronounced decline for more difficult stimuli, but no decline has been found for supposedly difficult emotions such as disgust, and there is evidence of decline for easily recognized emotions such as sadness (e.g., Calder et al, 2003; Emotion recognition in music and aging !…”

Theory of Mind (ToM) and counterfactuality deficits in schizophrenia: misperception or misinterpretation?

“…Thus far the APT has been used to assess attitudinal prosody in geriatric populations and is also currently used (Orbelo et al 2005) in neurological investigations of individuals with brain damage. In these studies patient groups tend to perform worse than comparison subjects on both affective prosody and the APT.…”

“…If subjects were confused by the instructions, further elaboration of the task instructions, using more commonplace synonyms, was provided. Subjects' scores reflected percent correct (Orbelo et al 2005). Additionally, scores were divided into percent correct of sincere and sarcastic items.…”

“…Sarcasm perception was assessed using the attitudinal subtest (APT) of the Aprosodia Battery (Orbelo et al 2005). This battery consists of 10 semantically neutral sentences, such as ' This looks like a safe boat ', that were recorded by a female speaker in both a sincere or sarcastic manner for a total of 20 distinct utterances.…”