Impacts of COVID-19 pandemic on professional identity development of intern nursing students in China: A scoping review

Abstract

Purpose Clinical experience plays a vital role in the development of the professional identity (PI) of nursing students. China has applied a strict zero- COVID health policy in combating the COVID-19 pandemic since December 2019 and studies have been conducted in different places of China to explore PI development of nursing students during the pandemic time among the intern nursing students who are on clinical practices. This review study aims to synthesize the previous studies and provide a comprehensive picture of the impacts of the pandemic on the PI development of intern nursing students. Methods Arksey and O’Malley’s five-stage scoping review framework was used. Combinations of keywords were used to search relevant articles in both Chinese and English databases published from inception of the articles until the final search date (10 March 2022). The initially included articles were also appraised for their quality, and those that passed the appraisal were left for data analysis. The analytic results were cross-checked among the reviewers. Result Three themes emerged from the included studies: 1) the PI levels, 2) the impacts of personal and social factors of PL, and 3) the specific impact of the COVID-19 pandemic. The levels of students’ PI ranged from 66%-80% of the total scores in PI instruments, almost the same levels as in pre-pandemic time, despite the elevated social image of nurses after the COVID-19 pandemic. There is no consensus about the impacts of most personal and social factors on students’ PI across the studies. The impacts of COVID-19 on PI were both positive and negative. Conclusions COVID-19 epidemic exerted complicated impacts on the PI of intern nursing students. While it is necessary to address the fear of the COVID-19 pandemic among intern nursing students, the pandemic may not be an opportunistic time to enhance the students’ PI.

Investigating the intentions and reasons of senior high school students in registering for nursing education in China

“…However, the image of heroism hides daily, mundane, dirty and gendered nursing work [ 42 ]. The praise and enthusiasm for nursing during COVID-19 may quickly fade away and may not result in profound impacts on the recruitment of nursing students according to the same phenomenon that occurred during the 2003 severe acute respiratory syndrome outbreak [ 43 ]. Politicians and policy-makers should turn their appreciation of nurses into positive actions.…”

Desafíos en la formación de profesionales de Enfermería durante la pandemia COVID-19 en la Universidad de Guayaquil: Una revisión bibliográfica

“…La práctica avanzada de enfermería se refiere al desarrollo de competencias complejas que fortalecen tanto el desarrollo de la profesión de enfermería como la mejora de la atención brindada al paciente (Faterström, 2012). Aunque normalmente es realizada por enfermeras con una larga trayectoria profesional y niveles académicos superiores al grado, la pandemia de COVID-19 ha obligado a los internos de enfermería a asumir tareas avanzadas de cuidado sin estar completamente capacitados (Luo & Mao, 2022).…”

Mediating effect of resilience between social support and compassion fatigue among intern nursing and midwifery students during COVID-19: a cross-sectional study

“…In addition, emotional ups and downs were heightened by witnessing patients infected, quarantined and dying in front of them [ 12 ]. Their compassion fatigue may not be apparent; however, it may later affect the quality of nursing and even the development of professional identity [ 13 , 14 ]. Furthermore, Stamm suggested that the presence of vulnerability factors (such as a lack of social support) and personal strengths (such as resilience) may explain the development of compassion fatigue [ 15 ].…”