Impact of trade controls on price transmission between southern African maize markets

Abstract

Maize is an important staple crop in Southern Africa that has often been prioritised from a policy perspective, particularly in the imposition of export controls under periods of perceived uncertainty. This tendency has been particularly relevant in Zambia, which has also emerged as an important surplus producer in Southern Africa in recent years. Its favourable transport differential and non-GM maize has helped Zambia grow its share in Zimbabwean maize imports at the expense of South Africa, but exports into Zimbabwe remains competitive between the two countries and particularly during periods of export control in Zambia, South Africa typically steps in to supply the deficit. This study therefore evaluates the extent of price transmission between Zambia, South Africa and Zimbabwe under two exogenous regimes defined by periods of open trade and trade controls imposed by the Zambian government. It uses secondary data of monthly white maize prices in these three markets to quantify the long and short run price relationships under different regimes. While several authors have noted that trade is not a prerequisite for price transmission between markets, this study finds evidence that the imposition of policies that inhibit trade also influences the rate and nature of price transmission between markets. Periods of open trade were characterised by efficient transmission of prices from Zambia to Zimbabwe, which is in line with typical trade patterns, but during periods of trade controls, no relationship was found between Zambian and Zimbabwean markets, with prices being transmitted from South Africa to Zimbabwe instead.

Determination of the international maize price: What is the growing role of Brazil and Ukraine?

“…Economic theory asserts that, in some circumstances, the quantity a country exports can influence the impact the exporting country has on global price determination. In general, underlying any price transmissions, there must be real or expected shipments of goods (Baulch, 1997;Davids, Ferdi, & Westhoff, 2017;Deodhar & Sheldon, 1997;Ghoshray, 2006;Goodwin & Piggott, 2001;Grigsby & Arnade, 1986;Sephton, 2003). That is, if maize shipments between countries permanently came to a halt, each country's price would be determined by its own demand and supply.…”

Impact of Grain Trade Policies on Prices and Welfare : Evidence from Malawi

“…This concern has prompted many researchers to examine the impact of trade controls on the efficiency and the degree of price transmission between markets within countries and across neighboring economies in Africa using a variety of statistical approaches. Davids, Meyer, and Westhoff (2017) use an autoregressive distributed lag model (ARDL) to look at price transmission between maize markets in Zambia, Zimbabwe, and South Africa. They find that under open trade policies, efficient price transmission occurs between the Zambia and Zimbabwe markets.…”

Infrastructure investments, regional trade agreements and agricultural market integration in Mozambique

“…Recently, Davids et al (2016) examined market integration for maize within the Eastern and Southern Africa region and the relationship between different markets across the three main regions (South, Centre and North) of Mozambique and markets in the cross-border countries. However, they did not test for integration across the markets in Mozambique.…”