Impact of trade and economic liberalisation policy reforms on the operations of selected small to medium enterprises (SMEs) in Zimbabwe : a comparative study with South Africa's experiences

Abstract

The study assesses the impact of trade and economic liberalisation policy reforms on the operations of selected manufacturing small to medium enterprises (SMEs) in Zimbabwe, and then compares the findings with experiences from South Africa’s SMEs. Motivation for the study was premised on two fronts. Zimbabwe and South Africa are currently faced with high unemployment rates (80% for Zimbabwe and 25% for South Africa). It therefore follows that job creation and poverty alleviation are the two pressing challenges facing the governments of Zimbabwe and South Africa. Secondly, the governments of Zimbabwe and South Africa have identified SMEs as the engines of economic growth with a special focus on addressing the twin challenges of unemployment and poverty alleviation. The roles and hopes bestowed on SMEs calls for a thriving and vibrant SME sector. On the other hand the adoption of trade liberalisation policies in the two countries has led some analysts to cast doubts on the ability of SMEs to withstand the fierce competition from established Multi-National Corporations and cheap imports. Employing a combined qualitative-quantitative approach, the study finds that trade and economic liberalisation policy had a negative impact on the operations of manufacturing small to medium enterprises in both Zimbabwe and South Africa. Cash-strapped SMEs have been strangled by resource-rich Multi-National Corporations. So dire is the situation that in the absence of significant government intervention, SMEs face an uncertain future. Compounding the matter is the fact that most SMEs in two countries are not involved in exports due to lack of knowledge and resources. The innovativeness ability of most SMEs remains very low. The study does not find significant differences on the impact of trade liberalisation policy reforms between SMEs in Zimbabwe and those in South Africa. It is recommended that the governments of Zimbabwe and South Africa need to introduce incentives to encourage SMEs to export and thus employ more people. Governments in Zimbabwe and South Africa need to factor in the transfer of technology to SMEs as one of the clauses when they negotiate the entry conditions of MNCs. In addition, the governments in Zimbabwe and South Africa must reintroduce tariffs in certain critical sectors of the economy to curtail cheap imports. It is cautioned that failure to protect SMEs could jeopardise the survival of most SMEs in Zimbabwe and South Africa, translating into increased unemployment, poverty and unequal wealth distribution.

A framework for stimulating adoption of ICT in SMEs in developing countries: The case of Zimbabwe

“…Zimbabwe was an ideal context for this research being a developing country with low-to-middle per capita income, where SMEs make up 95% of the country's business population. The country's population has, however, been labelled in various literature (Chingwaru, 2014;Tsarwe, 2014) as the most educated in Southern Africa, yet its SMEs have struggled with ICT adoption. Zimbabwe was also ideal for this paper as it is one of the researchers' country of birth and this facilitated the ease with which data could be collected, as the researcher was able to communicate effectively with participants using their native languages and could efficiently navigate through the country.…”

The effect of trade liberalization on SMEs performance in Nigeria

“…The results also suggest the key role of macroeconomic variables such as trade openness, interest rate, as well as bank credit, which do not support SME performance. In a related study, Chingwaru (2015) examined the effect of trade policy on SMEs operations, comparing findings for Zimbabwe and South Africa. Using a combination of qualitative and quantitative approaches, findings showed a negative impact of trade and economic liberalization policy on the operations of SMEs in both countries.…”

The effect of digital transformation on the productivity of business enterprises in South Africa

“…Exploring the connection between digital transformation and productivity reveals profound implications of the shift in the operational landscape of SMEs within the dynamic context of South Africa (Chingwaru, 2015). In a nation as diverse and yet intricate as South Africa, SMEs operate within a unique ecosystem, offering a range CITATION Obokoh L, Arogundade S, Sthembiso N, Akinola S (2024).…”