Impact of Public-Private-Partnership Programmes on Students’ Learning Outcomes: Evidence from a Quasi-Experiment

Abstract

Learning outcomes refer to the performance of the students in academic tests pertaining to the respective grade level. In Pakistan, survey evidences from Annual Status of Education Report (ASER) show a significant dispersion in learning outcomes of public schools as compared with private sector counterpart. The perceived results of learning outcomes in private schools very clear but less evidence is found for educational outcome of schools run under public-private partnership programs. This becomes especially relevant when status of curricular, co-curricular, and extra-curricular activities is compared between public school, private schools, and schools run under public private partnership. In recent literature, it is found that schools taken up by public-private partnership have been providing a better learning environment—Infrastructure Rehabilitation and Development, Administrative changes, Academic Innovation and Planning, Teacher Reform and Student Affairs—is perceived to have a positive impact on learning outcomes. It is to investigate and document that the investments in these areas are justifiable. To promote this fact, we conduct a quasi-experiment to examine the profiles of students in a public-private partnership school at Karachi (running under Zindagi Trust program) and a public school (as counterfactual) in the same neighbourhood. We also recorded the household and socioeconomic characteristics to create a good set of control variables. The propensity-score results show that public-private school is performing better than that of comparison group in attaining learning outcomes thus showing positive effects of PPP. Finally, the study probed into household and parental covariates of student's educational outcomes to enhance internal validity of results. JEL Classification: I21, C21, L32. Keywords: Educational Learning Outcomes, Public-Private Partnership, Quasi-experiment.

The performance advantage of public-private partnerships: does it exist or not?

“…Most studies to this effect, however, have focused on social infrastructure projects, such as health services (Cercone et al, 2005;Ferreira & Marques, 2021;Gauri et al, 2004;Shet et al, 2011), schools (Barrera-Osorio, 2007Hafeez et al, 2016;Rodrigues & Zucco, 2018;Yaya, 2017), and prisons (Archambeault & Deis, 1997;Cabral et al, 2010Cabral et al, , 2013Cabral & De Azevedo, 2008). The study by Cercone and colleagues comparatively analyzed seven health care clinics in Costa Rica (Cercone et al, 2005;Gauri et al, 2004).…”

Social justice leadership in rural Pakistan : a constructivist grounded theory study of private school leaders

“…They offer day and evening school at more than a hundred schools to accommodate many students, a reported 285,000 students in total. CARE pays for urgent expenses at the adopted government schools to implement high academic standards, set up science labs and libraries, hire school leaders, provide teacher training, and manage schools (Hafeez et al, 2016;Seema, 2012). Their efforts to improve schooling for marginalized students from a lower SES have seen a ~400 % increase in enrollment, a 10 % decrease in dropout, and increased students' academic achievement.…”