Impact of Productive Activities on Forest Cover Change in the Calakmul Biosphere Reserve Region: Evidence and Research Gaps

Abstract

Background and Research Aims Human activities seeking to satisfy various needs have resulted in deforestation and other forest cover change processes. The Natural Protected Areas are among the most efficient instruments to contain forest loss. The compensation from conservation is not sufficient to compete with land uses with higher economic rent, such as timber extraction and food production. This study summarizes the evidence and identifies research gaps on forest processes caused by productive activities in Mexico’s Calakmul Biosphere Reserve. Methods We systematically reviewed the scientific literature investigating forest processes caused by the productive activities in the Calakmul, including the transition zone. We calculated the frequencies of codes on forest processes and productive activities in the entire sample (53), evaluated each code’s significance in the qualitative synthesis and interpretation, and summarized the measurements of forest processes considering only the primary studies (46). Results Deforestation was the most commonly investigated process. Traditional agriculture initially caused deforestation, while livestock and conventional agriculture became more dominant recently with the agricultural intensification policies. Few articles investigated forest degradation experiencing a steady increase from fallow shortening and selective logging. Also, few studies identified forest recovery resulting from long fallows and core zone delimitation. No publications evaluated the forest cover impact of sustainable initiatives. Conclusion The tendency to quantify deforestation on a regional scale masks presence of other forest processes. The rural development programs in Calakmul did not include the environmental perspective, while participation in sustainable initiatives was low. The understanding of productive activities at the local level will allow differentiation of the long-term from temporary forest dynamic. Implications for Conservation To assure resilient and inclusive growth in Calakmul, the reduced-impact logging, sustainable agricultural intensification, improved fallows, and beekeeping should be supported with monetary resources that cover the transaction costs of unsustainable livestock breeding and industrial agriculture.

Gypsophily in tropical environments: a case study in the Yucatan Peninsula

“…Recent expansion of livestock farming in the region might also become a serious threat to biodiversity, even in areas considered unsuitable for milpa (a traditional agriculture system) (Špirić et al . 2022). An even more important driver of deforestation in this region is mechanised agriculture, which is replacing the milpa in Campeche (Špirić et al 2022).…”

“…2022). An even more important driver of deforestation in this region is mechanised agriculture, which is replacing the milpa in Campeche (Špirić et al 2022). Other agricultural practices such as the use of fire and changes in the agricultural cycles also have contributed to forest fragmentation in the region (Špirić et al 2022).…”

Differential utilization of surface and arboreal water bodies by birds and mammals in a seasonally dry Neotropical forest in southern Mexico

“…Together with the Maya Biosphere Reserve in Guatemala, the CBR constitutes the largest tract of tropical forest in Mesoamerica (Potapov et al., 2017 ). However, like most of the tropics, this region is under increasing human pressure due to activities such as illegal selective logging, hunting, deforestation for farming and cattle ranching, and more recently, infrastructure development (Ramírez‐Delgado et al., 2014 ; Špirić et al., 2022 ).…”