Impact of Personal Health Records and Wearables on Health Outcomes and Patient Response: Three-Arm Randomized Controlled Trial

Abstract

Background Although using the technologies for a variety of chronic health conditions such as personal health record (PHR) is reported to be acceptable and useful, there is a lack of evidence on the associations between the use of the technologies and the change of health outcome and patients’ response to a digital health app. Objective This study aimed to examine the impact of the use of PHR and wearables on health outcome improvement and sustained use of the health app that can be associated with patient engagement. Methods We developed an Android-based mobile phone app and used a wristband-type activity tracker (Samsung Charm) to collect data on health-related daily activities from individual patients. Dietary record, daily step counts, sleep log, subjective stress amount, blood pressure, and weight values were recorded. We conducted a prospective randomized clinical trial across 4 weeks on those diagnosed with obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) who had visited the outpatient clinic of Seoul National University Bundang Hospital. The trial randomly assigned 60 patients to 3 subgroups including 2 intervention groups: (1) mobile app and wearable device users (n=20), (2) mobile app–only users (n=20), and (3) controls (n=20). The primary outcome measure was weight change. Body weights before and after the trial were recorded and analyzed during clinic visits. Changes in OSA–related respiratory parameters such as respiratory disturbance, apnea-hypopnea, and oxygenation desaturation indexes and snoring comprised the secondary outcome and were analyzed for each participant. Results We collected the individual data for each group during the trial, specifically anthropometric measurement and laboratory test results for health outcomes, and the app usage logs for patient response were collected and analyzed. The body weight showed a significant reduction in the 2 intervention groups after intervention, and the mobile app–only group showed more weight loss compared with the controls ( P =.01). There were no significant changes in sleep-related health outcomes. From a patient response point of view, the average daily step counts (8165 steps) from the app plus wearable group were significantly higher than those (6034 steps) from the app-only group because they collected step count data from different devices ( P =.02). The average rate of data collection was not different in physical activity ( P =.99), food intake ( P =.98), sleep ( P =.95), stress ( P =.70), and weight ( P =.90) in the app plus wearable and app-only groups, respectively. Conclusions We tried to integrate PHR data that allow clinicians and patients to share lifelog data with the clinical workflow to support lifestyle interventions. Our results s...

New mHealth application software based on myofunctional therapy applied to sleep-disordered breathing in non-compliant subjects

“…The future treatment and diagnosis of this disease will be based on the use of Apps (Lim and Pack 2017), as shown by Kim et al (2019) We currently recommend that our patients use the App simultaneously with other daily diagnosis tools (Camacho et al 2015b) to provide objective feedback of their progress in their activity. One of the great advantages of this App is the possibility of contacting a therapist who can observe the daily evolution of the patients' exercises.…”

Automated-Entry Patient-Generated Health Data for Chronic Conditions: The Evidence on Health Outcomes

“…All three included sleep apnea trials were randomized. Kim et al (2019) 61 was conducted in South Korea (43 patients enrolled, 4-week followup, median patient enrollment month July 2017), Mendelson et al (2014) 47was conducted in France (107 patients enrolled, 17-week followup, median patient enrollment month October 2010), and Cho et al (2018) 62was conducted in South Korea (47 patients enrolled, 4-week followup, median patient enrollment month September 2016).…”

“…The next sections describe additional aspects of these trials, which are tabled in detail in Appendix Table C -17, C-18, and C-19. Kim et al (2019) 61 included obese/overweight adults with sleep apnea who could use a mobile app and a wearable device. Mendelson et al (2014) 47 included adults with sleep apnea and BMI <40 kg/m 2 with a high cardiovascular risk score (cardiovascular risk SCORE >5%) or history of cardiovascular disease.…”

Opportunities and Challenges Surrounding the Use of Data From Wearable Sensor Devices in Health Care: Qualitative Interview Study

“…Existing empirical studies of wearables in health care demonstrate the feasibility of creating technologies [ 14 ] and running data analytics [ 15 , 16 ]; small pilot studies have demonstrated the use of wearables in managing specific chronic conditions, including diabetes and high blood pressure, as well as contributing to data analytics [ 17 - 20 ]. There is also some evidence from trials that wearables can promote healthy behavior [ 21 - 23 ]. However, because these technologies have transformative potential, and there is limited adoption experience, their ultimate outcomes and significance cannot reliably be assessed at this moment.…”