Impact of network time-delay and force feedback on tele-surgery

Abstract

Object We have developed a robotic minimally invasive surgical system within a tele-surgery capability and conducted several times of tele-surgery experiments including Japan-Thailand and Japan-Korea tele-surgery experiments by using conventional network infrastructures. In these experiments, laparoscopic cholecystectomies have been successfully performed on pigs. On the other hand, repetitive task evaluation studies are also crucial for further studies on tele-surgery applications. Nowadays, task evaluations of tele-robotic system within network time-delay have been studied in past years by many researchers. These experiments have been mostly focused on simplified tasks such as a peg-in-hole task. However, most of surgical procedures in minimally invasive surgery are based on medical specific skills such as anatomical knowledge and past experiences of J. Arata (B) · H. Fujimoto surgeons. From these perspectives, a trial experiment within two tasks including surgery oriented manipulations was conducted to study the impact of network time-delay and force feedback on tele-surgery. Materials and methods The experiment was conducted by using the minimally invasive surgical system. As the experimental setup, a research and development Internet, JGN2 (Japan Gigabit Network 2) was used as a network infrastructure, and two tasks were performed by 15 subjects including 5 medical doctors. The trial conditions were given by changing time-delay (on the both tasks) and force feedback (on the first task). The first task was configured to test a simple surgical procedure, which is commonly performed in a laparoscopy as translational motions of surgical tools. The subjects were instructed to touch four columns located on points of a square. The second task was configured to test integrated surgical procedures. The subjects were instructed to perform a part of suturing procedures by using the robotic bending forceps. Results In the first task, the completion time was increased approximately 50% by time-delay. By using force feedback, the applied force was decreased. However, the effectiveness of force feedback was not strongly shown in MD group. On the other hand, the effectiveness of the force feedback was strongly shown in the applied force on the tip of surgical tool in both MD and non-MD groups. In the second task, the adverse impact of time-delay was not strongly shown in MD group. From the analysis of the motion records found that a skill of experienced surgeons on "occlusion problem" could be related in the results. These results indicate that skilful operators on surgical procedures can overcome the adverse impact of time-delay by introducing their skills depending on required surgical tasks. However, the drawback of timedelay still remains concerning on safety issues. The effectiveness of the force feedback was strongly shown in the 123

Surgeon-Centered Analysis of Robot-Assisted Needle Driving Under Different Force Feedback Conditions

“…Up to performing this research, several studies compared conditions with force feedback (usually one algorithm of force feedback) to no force feedback condition, and usually added another condition with the force feedback as visual information (Tholey et al, 2005;Arata et al, 2008;Gwilliam et al, 2009;Santos-Carreras et al, 2010;Talasaz et al, 2017). Results were inconclusive and were task dependent.…”

Implementing force-feedback in a telesurgery environment, using parameter estimation

“…In each case the tests have been performed using a local network at Aalborg University with the use of the network simulator Netem, for generating delays that are both known and reproducible 3 . When performing the tests all available joints have been used.…”

“…[3] have studied the combination of time-delay and force-feedback concluding that in a suturing task the skill of the surgeon outweighed the negative effects of 165 and 270 ms delay. Neither did force-feedback increase completion time for experienced surgeons, however it did significantly reduce forces exerted upon the sutured fabric.…”

Design and evaluation of a slave manipulator with roll‐pitch‐roll wrist and automatic tool loading mechanism in telerobotic surgery

“…Equation (8) is only established if the angle θ is within AE60 . As the operating range of the angle θ is from -90 to 90 , angular errors will be increased if we use equation (8). To find a linear equation similar to equation (5) over the whole operating range, points at equal intervals are sampled.…”