Impact of integrated health system changes, accelerated due to an earthquake, on emergency department attendances and acute admissions: a Bayesian change-point analysis

Abstract

ObjectiveTo chart emergency department (ED) attendance and acute admission following a devastating earthquake in 2011 which lead to Canterbury's rapidly accelerated integrated health system transformations.DesignInterrupted time series analysis, modelling using Bayesian change-point methods, of ED attendance and acute admission rates over the 2008–2014 period.SettingED department within the Canterbury District Health Board; with comparison to two other district health boards unaffected by the earthquake within New Zealand.ParticipantsCanterbury's health system services ∼500 000 people, with around 85 000 ED attendances and 37 000 acute admissions per annum.Main outcome measuresDe-seasoned standardised population ED attendance and acute admission rates overall, and stratified by age and sex, compared before and after the earthquake.ResultsAnalyses revealed five global patterns: (1) postearthquake, there was a sudden and persisting decrease in the proportion of the population attending the ED; (2) the growth rate of ED attendances per head of population did not change between the pre-earthquake and postearthquake periods; (3) postearthquake, there was a sudden and persisting decrease in the proportion of the population admitted to hospital; (4) the growth rate of hospital admissions per head of the population declined between pre-earthquake and postearthquake periods and (5) the most dramatic reduction in hospital admissions growth after the earthquake occurred among those aged 65+ years. Extrapolating from the projected and fitted deseasoned rates for December 2014, ∼676 (16.8%) of 4035 projected hospital admissions were avoided.ConclusionsWhile both necessarily and opportunistically accelerated, Canterbury's integrated health systems transformations have resulted in a dramatic and sustained reduction in ED attendances and acute hospital admissions. This natural intervention experiment, triggered by an earthquake, demonstrated that integrated health systems with high quality out-of-hospital care models are likely to successfully curb growth in acute hospital demand, nationally and internationally.

Evaluating Google, Twitter, and Wikipedia as Tools for Influenza Surveillance Using Bayesian Change Point Analysis: A Comparative Analysis

“…For instance, Bayesian change point analysis has been used to estimate when changes occurred in interest rate data [39], chromosomal microarray data [39], and cancer-related gene expression data [40]. This method was used to detect changes in emergency department attendance and hospital admissions after a health system transformation in a post-earthquake area [41]. Bayesian change point analysis has also been used to detect changes in the dynamics of an aquatic ecosystem such as the introduction of a nonnative species [42].…”

Response by Twin Italian Hub Hospitals in a Double Seismic Event: A Retrospective Observational Investigation

“…This catastrophe has led to the reorganization of the local healthcare system to rely progressively more on the hub that was less involved in the seismic event, which is likely one of the key factors in keeping mortality and performance stable (16)(17)(18)(19).…”

Hospital avoidance: an integrated community system to reduce acute hospital demand

“…A series of earthquakes occurred in Canterbury between 2010 and 2012, with a major quake in early 2011 causing 185 deaths and widespread damage to healthcare infrastructure, particularly Christchurch Hospital (McIntosh et al, 2012;Schluter et al, 2016). This disaster focussed urgent attention on the need for safe community options for acute care and resulted in accelerated development of several services in the ADMS.…”