Impact of Insolation Data Source on Remote Sensing Retrievals of Evapotranspiration over the California Delta

Abstract

The energy delivered to the land surface via insolation is a primary driver of evapotranspiration (ET)-the exchange of water vapor between the land and atmosphere. Spatially distributed ET products are in great demand in the water resource management community for real-time operations and sustainable water use planning. The accuracy and deliverability of these products are determined in part by the characteristics and quality of the insolation data sources used as input to the ET models. This paper investigates the practical utility of three different insolation datasets within the context of a satellite-based remote sensing framework for mapping ET at high spatiotemporal resolution, in an application over the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta region in California. The datasets tested included one reanalysis product: The Climate System Forecast Reanalysis (CFSR) at 0.25 • spatial resolution, and two remote sensing insolation products generated with geostationary satellite imagery: a product for the continental United States at 0.2 • , developed by the University of Wisconsin Space Sciences and Engineering Center (SSEC) and a coarser resolution (1 • ) global Clouds and the Earth's Radiant Energy System (CERES) product. The three insolation data sources were compared to pyranometer data collected at flux towers within the Delta region to establish relative accuracy. The satellite products significantly outperformed CFSR, with root-mean square errors (RMSE) of 2.7, 1.5, and 1.4 MJ·m −2 ·d −1 for CFSR, CERES, and SSEC, respectively, at daily timesteps. The satellite-based products provided more accurate estimates of cloud occurrence and radiation transmission, while the reanalysis tended to underestimate solar radiation under cloudy-sky conditions. However, this difference in insolation performance did not translate into comparable improvement in the ET retrieval accuracy, where the RMSE in daily ET was 0.98 and 0.94 mm d −1 using the CFSR and SSEC insolation data sources, respectively, for all the flux sites combined. The lack of a notable impact on the aggregate ET performance may be due in part to the predominantly clear-sky conditions prevalent in central California, under which the reanalysis and satellite-based insolation data sources have comparable accuracy. While satellite-based insolation data could improve ET retrieval in more humid regions with greater cloud-cover frequency, over the California Delta and climatologically similar regions in the western U.S., the CFSR data may suffice for real-time ET modeling efforts. IntroductionEvapotranspiration (ET) describes the rate of exchange of water vapor between the land surface and the atmosphere, including water directly evaporated from the soil, open water, and other surfaces (E), as well as water consumed and transpired by plants in the process of biophysical development (T). The ability to accurately estimate ET spatially and temporally over large areas is critical to a broad range of applications, for example, in managing water resources, in assessing agricultu...

Reviews and syntheses: Ongoing and emerging opportunities to improve environmental science using observations from the Advanced Baseline Imager on the Geostationary Operational Environmental Satellites

“…Estimates of GPP often rely on LUE models, which are rooted in a linear relationship between absorbed PAR (APAR) and net primary production (Medlyn, 1998;Monteith, 1972). An ideal LUE in the absence of environmental stresses is specified and attenuated with the use of stress functions that describe the relationship between LUE and environmental stressors (Anderson et al, 2000;Mahadevan et al, 2008;Robinson et al, 2018;Running et al, 2004;Yuan et al, 2007;Zhang et al, 2016;Zhao et al, 2005). The most widely used environmental stressors include functions to describe temperature and moisture stress on LUE.…”

Using High-Spatiotemporal Thermal Satellite ET Retrievals for Operational Water Use and Stress Monitoring in a California Vineyard

“…This thermal-based approach has been successfully applied over multiple landcover types [23,[32][33][34][35][36][37][38], including vineyards [39,40]. The vineyard-specific applications of the ALEXI/DisALEXI modeling scheme demonstrated utility in monitoring vine water use and stress, capturing within-vineyard spatial heterogeneity of ET a and matching tower observations.…”

Reviews and syntheses: Ongoing and emerging opportunities to improve environmental science using observations from the Advanced Baseline Imager on the Geostationary Operational Environmental Satellites

“…4.1), giving optimal spatial and temporal correspondence between net radiation forcings and surface temperature response signals. In comparison with other sources of insolation data, geostationary-based insolation could improve significantly ET retrievals particularly in areas of frequent cloud cover where reanalysis estimates may not accurately capture the timing and spatial extents of clouds (Anderson et al, 2019;S. Ha et al, 2020).…”