Impact of economic recessions on healthcare workers and their crises’ responses: study protocol for a systematic review of the qualitative and quantitative evidence for the development of an evidence-based conceptual framework

Abstract

IntroductionDuring economic recessions, health professionals face reduced income and labour opportunities, hard conditions often exacerbated by governments’ policy responses to crises. Growing evidence points to non-negligible effects on national health workforces and health systems—decrease in motivation, burnout, migration—arising from the combination of crisis-related factors. However, no theoretical conceptualisation currently exists framing the impacts recessions have on human resources for health (HRH), or on their reactions.Methods and analysisThis paper lays out a protocol for a systematic review of the existing qualitative, quantitative and mixed-method evidence on the economic recessions and HRH; results from the review will be used to develop a conceptual framework linking existing theories on recessions, austerity measures, health systems and population health, with a view of informing future health policies. Eight relevant databases within the health, health systems, multidisciplinary and economic literature will be searched, complemented by secondary searches and experts’ input. Eligible studies will present primary quantitative or qualitative evidence on HRH impacts, or original secondary analyses. We will cover the 1970–2019 period—the modern age of global economic recessions—and full texts in English, Spanish, Italian, French, Portuguese or Greek. Two reviewers will independently assess, perform data extraction and conduct quality appraisal of the texts identified. A ‘best-fit’ framework synthesis will be applied to summarise the findings, using an a priori, theoretically driven framework. That preliminary framework was built by the research team to inform the searches, and will be appraised by external experts.Ethics and disseminationIn addition to peer-reviewed publications, the new framework will be presented in global health systems research conferences and inform regional policy dialogue workshops in Latin America on economic recessions and health systems.PROSPERO registration numberCRD42019134165.

A ‘new normal’ following COVID-19 and the economic crisis: Using systems thinking to identify challenges and opportunities in disability, telework, and rehabilitation

“…This then uncover the vast diversity in the sectors in which rehabilitation providers practice. The effects of economic crises in health workers is a policy concern; and scientific area of study for the health workers in general [79] but not for rehabilitation workers in particular [80]. The exact effect of this economic crisis, which is originated by a public health crisis, will be challenging to understand given apparent the lack of evidence.…”

How the ‘plates’ of a health system can shift, change and adjust during economic recessions: A qualitative interview study of public and private health providers in Brazil’s São Paulo and Maranhão states

“…We drew from the literature on economic recessions, health systems and human resources for health [ 36 ], as well as from our project’s conceptualization of the links between crises and health systems to identify relevant questions [ 20 ]. Our starting hypotheses were that the macro effects of a recession transmit to health sectors via austerity measures, impacts on the demand for services, and changes in the labour market; these are felt unevenly across the different parts of a health system, as they are mediated by pre-existing conditions (poverty and epidemiological profile), as well as role and degree of development of the private sector.…”

Mapping the occupational therapy workforce research worldwide: Study protocol for a scoping review

“…The strategy will be then translated to the search facilities of the other electronic databases. The process will be run by a researcher (TJ) with an extensive track record of conducting rehabilitation scoping reviews and designing search strategies for locating rehabilitation-related and/or health workforce content in scientific databases [26,[45][46][47][48][49][50][51][52][53][54][55][56]. Snowballing search strategies (e.g., references lists search, citation tracking, author tracking) over included articles will also be conducted as a means to identify any additional references.…”