Impact of deviation from target working capital on firm profitability: evidence from India

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to assess the impact of deviation from the target investment in working capital (WC) (measured by net trade cycle (NTC)) on the profitability (measured by gross operating income (GOI) and net operating income (NOI)) of the listed non-financial Indian firms. Design/methodology/approach The study is based on the data collected on NTC, GOI, NOI and other variables pertaining to 242 listed non-financial Indian firms that form part of the Bombay Stock exchange 500 Index for the period 2012–2017 (1,452 firm-year observations). Following Banos-Caballero et al. (2010), the authors use a firm fixed effect regression as the benchmark regression for finding out the determinants of NTC of the sample firms. Furthermore, this study explores the impact of deviation (above and below target) from the target investments in WC on the firm profitability (GOI and NOI) employing fixed effect regression. Findings The result of this study reveals that Indian firms maintain a target NTC and try to converge in case of any deviations to it. Furthermore, the profitability of the sample firms was observed to be influenced by the deviation from the target NTC irrespective of whether the deviation was above or below the target investment level in WC. Practical implications This study highlights the importance of good WC management for firms due to the negative impact of the over- and under-investments in WC and contributes to the existing body of knowledge by suggesting that managers should keep close to the target WC and not deviate from this in order to maximize the firms’ profitability. Originality/value To the best of the knowledge of the researchers, this is perhaps the first study to examine the impact of firms’ deviation from their target investment in WC on the profitability for non-financial firms listed and operating in India.

Working Capital and Earnings Management among Manufacturing Firms: A Review of Literature

“…There have been numerous studies on working capital with different researchers adopting different proxies for measuring WCM. Some researchers adopted the use of cash conversion cycle in measuring WCM (Mathuva, 2015;Deloof, 2003;Shin and Soenen, 1998, Kieschnick et al, 2006and Baños-Caballero et al, 2012, others adopted Net trade cycles and weighted average cash conversion cycle (Prasad et al, 2019) whereas others adopted Net working capital and cashflow from operations (Ashhari, 2012).…”

Impact of Loan Accessibility on Working Capital Management and Profitability: Comparative Study of Family Versus Non-Family Firms

“…Successful WCM is essential for the company's sustainability and growth, as it influences the productivity and liquidity position of the businesses (Deloof, 2003;Prasad et al, 2019). An inadequate WCM reflects poor administration of firm regarding fund management and credit policies that often lead towards liquidation (Bhunia & Das, 2015).…”

“…Working capital management (WCM) has become quite popular for the academicians and practitioners for analyzing the firm's performance (Prasad, Sivasankaran, & Shukla, 2019). Chauhan and Banerjee (2018) stated that the sound administration of working capital is significant for any organization particularly, for those that are working in the emerging economies with restricted access to the capital market and long-term investment.…”

Business Strategies: An Antidote to Firm Profitability of Selected Flour Milling Companies in Nigeria

“…Estrada, and Dong (2019) contributed that firm profitability is the total income earned by the enterprise during the specified period of time. Prasad, Sivasankaran, and Shukla (2019) argued that firm profitability is the operating efficiency of the enterprise which could be explained as profitability. Ahmad, Li, and Tian (2019) contributed that is the ability for the enterprise to make profit on sales, while Pellegrini, Caruso, and Cifone (2019) sees it as the ability for the enterprise to get sufficient return on the capital and employee used in the business operations.…”