Impact of conditional and unconditional cash transfers on health outcomes and use of health services in humanitarian settings: a mixed-methods systematic review

Abstract

BackgroundCash transfers, payments provided by formal or informal institutions to recipients, are increasingly used in emergencies. While increasing autonomy and being supportive of local economies, cash transfers are a cost-effective method in some settings to cover basic needs and extend benefits of limited humanitarian aid budgets. Yet, the extent to which cash transfers impact health in humanitarian settings remains largely unexplored. This systematic review evaluates the evidence on the effect of cash transfers on health outcomes and health service utilisation in humanitarian contexts.MethodsStudies eligible for inclusion were peer reviewed (quantitative,qualitative and mixed-methods). Nine databases (PubMed, EMBAS, Medline, CINAHL, Global Health, Scopus, Web of Science Core Collection, SciELO and LiLACS) were searched without language and without a lower bound time restriction through 24 February 2021. The search was updated to include articles published through 8 December 2021. Data were extracted using a piloted extraction tool and quality was assessed using The Joanna Briggs Critical Appraisal Tool. Due to heterogeneity in study designs and outcomes, results were synthesised narratively and no meta-analysis was performed.Results30 673 records were identified. After removing duplicates, 17 715 were double screened by abstract and title, and 201 in full text. Twenty-three articles from 16 countries were included reporting on nutrition outcomes, psychosocial and mental health, general/subjective health and well-being, acute illness (eg, diarrhoea, respiratory infection), diabetes control (eg, blood glucose self-monitoring, haemoglobin A1C levels) and gender-based violence. Nineteen studies reported some positive impacts on various health outcomes and use of health services, 11 reported no statistically significant impact on outcomes assessed and 4 reported potential negative impacts on health outcomes.DiscussionAlthough there is evidence to suggest a positive relationship between cash transfers and health outcomes in humanitarian settings, high-quality empirical evidence, that is methodologically robust, investigates a range of humanitarian settings and is conducted over longer time periods is needed. This should consider factors influencing programme implementation and the differential impact of cash transfers designed to improve health versus multipurpose cash transfers.PROSPERO registration numberCRD42021237275.

COVID-19 lockdowns and children’s health and well-being

“…While the Ehsaas cash transfer program in Pakistan has been praised for its coverage and ability to help the most venerable households, it is not currently designed to provide additional assistance to children who work. With previous literature showing cash transfers can be effective in aiding health and well-being in crises settings such as pandemics (see van Daalen et al (2022) for a recent review), our results indicate providing cash transfers based on child work status may be a fruitful avenue for policy makers to explore.…”

Effects of Nutrition Counselling and Unconditional Cash Transfer on Child Growth and Family Food Security in Internally Displaced Person Camps in Somalia—A Quasi-Experimental Study

“…The link between UCT and nutrition is well researched and documented in several studies [ 32 , 33 , 34 ]. However, the amount of CT differs across countries.…”

An Unconditional Cash Transfer Program for Low-Income New Yorkers Affected by COVID-19

“…Studies of cash transfer programs, while heterogeneous in quality and findings, suggest that such interventions may have positive impacts on health [ 9 – 13 ]. Cash transfer programs have been implemented across the globe in response to the COVID-19 pandemic, with international studies finding effects on food security and access to healthcare [ 14 – 16 ].…”