Background:
In 2006, Cancer Care Ontario created Surgical Oncology Standards for the delivery of HPB surgery including hepatectomy and pancreaticoduodenectomy (PD). Our objective was to identify the impact of standardization on outcomes after hepatopancreatobiliary (HPB) surgery in Ontario, Canada.
Study Design:
Population-level analysis of patients undergoing hepatectomy or PD (2003–2019). Logistic regression models were used to compare 30- and 90-day mortality and length of stay (LOS), before (2003-2006), during (2007-2011) and after (2012-2019) standardization. Interrupted time series (ITS) models were used to co-analyze secular trends.
Results:
A total of 7,904 hepatectomies and 5,238 PDs were performed. >80% of all cases were performed at a designated center (DC) before standardization. This increased to >98% in the post-standardization era. Median volumes at DCs increased from 55 to 67 hepatectomies/year, and 22 to 50 PDs/year over time. 30-day mortality after hepatectomy was 2.6% before, and 2.3% post-standardization (p=0.9). 30-day mortality after PD was 3.6% before, and 2.4% post-standardization (p=0.1). Multivariable analyses revealed a significant difference in 90-day mortality following PD post-standardization (4.3% vs. 6.3%; aOR 0.7, p=0.03). Median LOS was shorter for hepatectomy (6 days vs. 8 days) and PD (9 days vs. 14 days; p<0.0001), after standardization. Immediate and late effects on mortality and LOS were likely attributable to secular trends, which pre-dated standardization.
Conclusion:
Standardization was associated with a higher volume of hepatectomy and PDs with further concentration of care at DCs. Pre-existing quality initiatives may have attenuated the effect of standardization on quality outcomes. Our data highlight the merits of a multi-faceted provincial system for enabling consistent access to high quality HPB care throughout a region of 15-million people over a 16-year period.