Impact of Acid–Base Stimulation Sequence on Mineral Stability for Tight/Impermeable Unconventional Carbonate-Rich Rocks: A Delaware Basin Case Study

Abstract

Mineral precipitation due to reactions with injected fluids during unconventional fracture stimulation is a well-recognized problem. The goal of this study is to evaluate secondary mineral precipitation and permeability attenuation under chemical injection scenarios specific to the Delaware basin. Whole cylindrical cores (2.54 cm diameter and 2.54 cm height) and ground shale (150−250 μm) from the carbonate-rich Bone Spring Formation, Delaware Basin TX (Leonardian), were reacted at 80 °C and 85 bar using a hydraulic fracturing fluid (HFF) recipe and an injection sequence typical of the Delaware Basin. The reacted shales and solutions were analyzed using a variety of laboratory-and synchrotron-based techniques to characterize both the chemical and spatial distributions of secondary mineral precipitation and identify changes in permeability and mineralogy. This carbonaterich shale (>84% calcite) rapidly neutralized the acidic HFF. Synchrotron-based X-ray fluorescence mapping coupled with X-ray absorption spectroscopy (both bulk and micro) showed that most of the iron was in an oxidized form prior to exposure to HFF and that almost all iron(II) became fully oxidized after the reaction. Scanning electron microscopy images of the ground shale samples primarily identified iron(oxyhydr)oxide microcrystals on grain surfaces. A few small isolated iron-rich areas also contained sulfur, suggesting that some pyrite was preserved when isolated within a calcite crystal but that most was oxidized. The rapid neutralization of the acid spearhead in these carbonate-rich samples demonstrates that the acid spearhead is useful for initiating fractures in extremely calcite-rich rocks but does little to enhance rock permeability. This suggests that the impact of the acid spearhead is significantly smaller for carbonate-rich shales compared to clay-rich shales, which has broad implications for acidizing in carbonate-rich shale formations and iron transformations within these shales.