Immigrant crime in Norway and Finland

Abstract

Immigrants are known to be overrepresented in the crime statistics of Nordic countries. However, the composition of immigrant populations varies across countries both in terms of immigrants' country of origin as well as their population structure (age and sex). Cross-country comparison of crime rates is always difficult because of differences in legal systems, but it is even more challenging when using very broad categories of immigrants, lumping heterogeneous groups together. Previous studies have largely compared the entire immigrant population of a country with the majority population, which under-appreciates the heterogeneity that exists across immigrant groups. In this paper, we compare the crime rates in Norway and Finland, while adding additional nuances by reporting crime rates for 25 specific immigrant groups relative to the majority population. The data are gathered from Finnish and Norwegian administrative records, representing or comprising the resident population aged 15 -64. We analyse both violent crime and property crime, and we present the results adjusted for population structure (sex and age). The results show considerable similarity in the rank order of crime rates of immigrant groups in the two Nordic countries. Although the current study is mainly descriptive, it aims to set some limits to what it is to be explained. In fact, the diversity is so great that it is questionable whether one should treat immigrants as one single group at all. Whatever the causal mechanisms driving immigrant crime are, it seems plausible that some similar processes are operating across the Nordic region.

Intimate partner homicide, immigration and citizenship: evidence from Norway 1990–2012

“…Others assert that established psychological and criminological theories of IPH should be expected to generalize across population groups, covering both immigrant and native populations (e.g. Skardhamar, Aaltonen, & Lehti, 2014). To be sure, if certain groups are found to have greater involvement in registered crime, then increased attention to those groups is warranted.…”

Are Immigration Policy Preferences Based on Accurate Stereotypes?

“…If stereotypes about origin country groups reflect underlying reality, they should be similar across countries because groups that do well in one European country generally do well in other countries as well (Kirkegaard, 2014;Skardhamar, Aaltonen, & Lehti, 2014). Carl (2016), and Kirkegaard and Bjerrekaer (2016).…”

Immigration and crime: a time-trend analysis of self-reported crime in Sweden, 1999–2017

“…Although the vast majority of Swedish studies suggest that immigrants are overrepresented in crime by comparison with the native born population (see Kardell, 2010 for a review), no studies have yet examined whether this gap is increasing or decreasing and whether the direction and rate of change in crime trends differs across immigrant groups and immigrant generations. Immigrants and their children are characterized by considerable heterogeneity in terms of socioeconomic status, levels of social integration, and cultural factorsimplying that the dynamics of crime may not be identical for all immigrants (Skardhamar, Aaltonen, & Lehti, 2014). However, immigrants have generally been studied as a single group, resulting in little knowledge about potential changes in the delinquent involvement of different immigrant groups over time.…”