Immersive virtual reality applications for design reviews: Systematic literature review and classification scheme for functionalities

Horvat, Nikola; Kunnen, Steffen; Štorga, Mario; Nagarajah, Arun; Škec, Stanko

doi:10.1016/j.aei.2022.101760

Cited by 12 publications

(5 citation statements)

References 111 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…While the merging of physical and digital into a single interface is well-studied, the recent maturation of MR-capable technologies has enabled their application in domains ranging from education (Hallmann et al, 2023), to architecture (Kim and Hyun, 2022), to design (Verlinden and Horváth, 2009). Several works have highlighted the importance of the viewing interface for design performance (Berni et al, 2023;Horvat et al, 2022;Nandy et al, 2023) noting differences when using XR compared to traditional modes. Benefits of XR implementation for design have been shown to be broad, including enhanced spatial reasoning (Horvat et al, 2022), divergence (Sopher et al, 2022), confidence and satisfaction with outcomes (Kim and Hyun, 2022), and collaboration (Bisson et al, 2023).…”

Section: Extended Reality Technologies In Designmentioning

confidence: 99%

“…Several works have highlighted the importance of the viewing interface for design performance (Berni et al, 2023;Horvat et al, 2022;Nandy et al, 2023) noting differences when using XR compared to traditional modes. Benefits of XR implementation for design have been shown to be broad, including enhanced spatial reasoning (Horvat et al, 2022), divergence (Sopher et al, 2022), confidence and satisfaction with outcomes (Kim and Hyun, 2022), and collaboration (Bisson et al, 2023).…”

Section: Extended Reality Technologies In Designmentioning

confidence: 99%

“…References for works: A(Scurati et al, 2023), B(Hu et al, 2023), C(Latif et al, 2023), D(Trump and Shealy, 2023), E(Nanjappan et al, 2023), F(Steinhauser et al, 2023), G(Horvat et al, 2022), H(Berni et al, 2023), I(Nandy et al, 2023), J(Hireche et al, 2023), K(Bisson et al, 2023), L(Hallmann et al, 2023), M(Harlan et al, 2023), N(Brunzini et al, 2021), O(Yengui and Stechert, 2021), P(Seybold and Mantwill, 2021), Q(Porro et al, 2022), R(Goethem et al, 2021), S(Mariani et al, 2021), T(Romero et al, 2021), U(Kujur et al, 2022), V(Melo et al, 2022) 3 See https://tinyurl.com/DMFdrill, https://tinyurl.com/DMFcontroller, https://dmf-lab.co.uk/our-lab/…”

mentioning

confidence: 99%

See 2 more Smart Citations

Mixed reality prototyping: a framework to characterise simultaneous physical/virtual prototyping

Snider,

Kukreja,

Cox

et al. 2024

Proc. Des. Soc.

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Immersive reality (XR) technologies, particularly Mixed Reality (MR), offer promising opportunities for enhancing design prototyping. While recent studies often focus on Virtual Reality this work explores the application of MR, where focus lies on interlinking both the physical and digital to maximise benefit. Following a review of XR in design, a descriptive framework is presented to characterise MR prototyping. Two case studies are then presented to highlight the value of bridging the physical and digitalf worlds, before directions for further research in MR-based prototyping are outlined.

show abstract

Section: Extended Reality Technologies In Designmentioning

confidence: 99%

Section: Extended Reality Technologies In Designmentioning

confidence: 99%

mentioning

confidence: 99%

See 1 more Smart Citation

Mixed reality prototyping: a framework to characterise simultaneous physical/virtual prototyping

Snider,

Kukreja,

Cox

et al. 2024

Proc. Des. Soc.

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…Participants verbally communicated using Microsoft Teams, while the design solution was visualised in the form of a 3D model using a VR-enabled CAD system (i.e., Siemens NX). Siemens NX VR enables synchronous work on the same model using similar functions as in DI (screenshot, measure, marker, section, move, and hide parts) (Horvat, Kunnen, Štorga, Nagarajah, et al, 2022), moving around the virtual room (3x3 meters), and seeing each other's avatars (i.e., VR helmets), controllers, and laser pointers. A checklist related to the transition goal was also visualised using a PDF viewer, which could be accessed within the VR.…”

Section: Experimental Setup and Proceduresmentioning

confidence: 99%

Is It Better? Exploring the Effect of Transition Goal and Virtual Reality on Team Performance

et al. 2023

Self Cite

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Transition activities, such as design reviews, are often utilised in product development to evaluate the conducted work and plan future actions. While key decisions are made during these activities, they are still underexplored. This paper studies the effect of transition goals and virtual reality (VR) on transition team performance. In an experimental study, four-member teams conducted two transition-related experimental tasks (validation and verification) working in one of the two conditions (VR or desktop interface). The results show that transition goals and VR affect performance. More specifically, the validation-oriented transition was more efficient but less effective than the verification one. Furthermore, the performance of the validation-oriented transition compared to the verification one was increased in VR and decreased in a desktop interface. Finally, the high-performing teams consistently discussed new issues, while low-performing teams had prolonged moments of not discussing anything new. These findings suggest that desktop interface and VR are not substitutable but rather complementary technologies.

show abstract

“…XR enhances the capabilities of these tools by providing immersive and interactive environments for design, modelling, and engineering tasks. XR technology not only improves the design and visualization process but also supports collaborative efforts by allowing geographically dispersed teams to work together in shared virtual spaces, further addressing the demand for remote collaboration in CAD/CAE [7,8,4]. While XR can be quite useful and can add a lot of value to CAD/CAE software, it is worth establishing where that value can be added within CAD/CAE software and what functionalities of features XR can bring to CAD/CAE tool.…”

Section: Introductionmentioning

confidence: 99%

How Can XR Enhance Collaboration with CAD/CAE Tools in Remote Design Reviews?

Garcia Rivera,

Rostami,

Mattsson

et al. 2024

Advances in Transdisciplinary Engineering

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

This study studies the challenges of effective communication and collaboration in remote design review meetings (DRMs) and explores the potential of Extended Reality (XR) technologies to address these challenges. The research focuses on identifying recurring communication issues and the preferences of companies within the context of remote DRMs. The study involves qualitative content analysis and industry workshops to uncover the current problems with conventional approaches and the aspirations of companies regarding improved collaboration in the DRM process. Drawing upon the insights gathered from both the workshop and design review observations, this paper highlights the features that are critical for collaborative software to handle online design reviews. XR technologies offer immersive and interactive experiences that can transform communication and collaboration in the context of DRMs. By identifying the specific challenges faced in remote DRMs and understanding the desires of companies, this study sets the stage for a more efficient and effective collaborative process. It emphasizes the adaptability of XR technologies to meet industry needs and integrate seamlessly into existing workflows. The study concludes by highlighting the potential for XR technologies to enhance collaboration in DRMs, making them a valuable tool for various industries.

show abstract

Immersive virtual reality applications for design reviews: Systematic literature review and classification scheme for functionalities

Cited by 12 publications

References 111 publications

Mixed reality prototyping: a framework to characterise simultaneous physical/virtual prototyping

Mixed reality prototyping: a framework to characterise simultaneous physical/virtual prototyping

Is It Better? Exploring the Effect of Transition Goal and Virtual Reality on Team Performance

How Can XR Enhance Collaboration with CAD/CAE Tools in Remote Design Reviews?

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About