“…We can do likewise for the path γ 1 to obtain the matching cycle V t 1 . By the same argument, for any t > 0, we can take a straight line path given by the interval [1,3], which goes over the central critical point at 2, and say that this too will define a matching cycle: in the central nonsmooth fibre, we shall either get, by S 1 -symmetry, the critical point or some circle. However, if we obtain the critical point, then we would have found a Lagrangian in a homology class of positive symplectic area.…”