Illness perception in pediatric somatization and asthma: complaints and health locus of control beliefs

Abstract

BackgroundHealth- and illness-related cognitions of pediatric patients with asthma or somatization and of their caregivers are considered relevant for patient education and for cognitive-behavioral interventions. This study investigates the relationship between diagnosis and illness perception by child and parent in two different chronic conditions such as somatization disorder and asthma.Methods25 patients with somatoform disorders and 25 patients with asthma bronchiale completed the Giessen Complaint List and the Multidimensional Health Locus of Control Scale. Primary caregivers independently answered parallel proxy-report instruments. Analyses of variance were performed to determine the impact of diagnosis and perspective. Correlations were calculated to determine the concordance between patient and caregiver reports.ResultsNo statistically significant differences in illness locus of control beliefs were found between asthma and somatoform disorder children or parents. Parents reported more internal and fatalistic locus of control beliefs compared with their children. Correlations between patient and caregiver reports of symptoms and health locus of control beliefs were low to moderate.ConclusionClinicians should take into account a sense of insufficient symptom control in both diagnostic groups and different viewpoints of patients and their parents.

Understanding Treatment Adherence With the Health Belief Model in Children With Cystic Fibrosis

“…Furthermore, many studies rely on parent report of health beliefs and have not included children as participants (DiMatteo, Haskard, & Williams, 2007). Parents and children are both involved in chronic medical regimens, though they often have significantly different health beliefs about these treatments (Goldbeck & Bundschuh, 2007; Upton, Lawford, & Eiser, 2008; Vowles, Cohen, McCracken, & Esscleston, 2010). Parents’ perceptions and knowledge is not an adequate representation on children’s interpretations and parents do not always have a direct influence on children’s understanding or health beliefs (Campbell, 1975).…”

Factors influencing adherence to therapeutic recommendations made after diagnostic reassessment of medically unexplained symptoms in children and adolescents

“…However, it may also be the case that these risk factors do not apply to somatoform disorders. It is reasonable to assume that in this group, patients' (and their parents') views on the likely cause and preferred treatment of their symptoms are very different from the caregivers' diagnosis and advice (Goldbeck & Bundschuh, 2007), in contrast to somatic disorders. While patients with somatoform disorders tend to see their symptoms as a (purely) somatic problem, the treatments they are offered are usually not somatic in nature.…”

Turkish validity and reliability of Multidimensional Health Locus of Control Scale Form A

“…In addition, the MHLC Form A has been used in many nursing studies, including investigating the effectiveness of treatment in patients with chronic low back pain (Keedy, Keffala, Altmaier, & Chen, 2014;Sengul, Kara, & Arda, 2010), assessing how schizophrenia patients and their first-degree relatives (caregivers) understand each other, and the therapeutic interventions used to help them (Thakral, Bhatia, Gettig, Nimgaonkar, & Deshpande, 2014), and analysing the success of family-oriented psycho-education (cognitive and behavioural) interventions (Goldbeck & Bundschuh, 2007). Demonstration of its validity and reliability in the Turkish translation is therefore important.…”