“If you could just see me”: The construction of heterosexual men’s sexual selves and the hierarchy of desirability

Abstract

<jats:p> Part of identity development involves the construction of a sexual self. Sexual selves are constructed based on interactions with others. Based on in-depth interviews with 59 heterosexual men between the ages of 30 and 59, I look at the way research participants defined heterosexual men’s desirability through their framing of their sexual selves. I show how participants’ stories revealed a link between desirability and masculinity for heterosexual men in U.S. culture. Moreover, I find that consistent with narratives of hegemonic masculinity, men were concerned with proving their desirability and hetero-masculinity through what I call “evidentiary stories.” These stories focused on men’s telling of how they were seen by others or in other contexts, with such accounts serving as evidence of their desirability. Through these stories, men constructed sexual selves that met (or failed to meet) dominant narratives of hetero-masculine desirability. In so doing, men also participated in the construction of a hierarchy of desirability among heterosexual men, underscoring the idea that certain men are more sought-after or valued than others—both by women partners and others at large. </jats:p>

The Battle for “NoFap”: Myths, Masculinity, and the Meaning of Masturbation Abstention

“…As Jones (2015) has argued, the ubiquity in digital culture of on-going self-measurement and auto-diagnosis constitutes the “entextualization of the self,” which works to increase a sense of agency through building a narrative where the individual is the hero of their own story. Self-Masters are also clearly jockeying for their position in the masculine hierarchy through specific “evidentiary stories” (Montemurro 2020). The role that NoFap plays for the Self-Master is a strong form of the transmutation thesis.…”

“Dabo Wears Male Rompers”: Examining Expressions of Hegemonic Masculinity and Identity in ESPN’s College GameDay

“…Thus, two of the three female guest pickers between 2015-2019 functioned as symbols of male heterosexuality and masculine hegemony, which is important not only in the context of hegemonic masculinity, but for heterosexual men's sense of selves. According to Montemurro (2021), heterosexual men perform their heterosexuality in a variety of ways, including through the construction of their "sexual selves that [meet] (or failed to meet) dominant narratives of hetero-masculine desirability" (p. 304). This sense of sexual selfhood comes through a variety of reinforcements, including a constant demonstration of heterosexuality and evidentiary stories of successful heterosexual relationships and sexual encounters, both of which operate against the backdrop of culturally-sanctioned hegemonic masculinity.…”

Climax as Work: Heteronormativity, Gender Labor, and the Gender Gap in Orgasms

“…hegemonic masculinity, in particular, proffers a heteromasculine ideal of men's sexual prowess based on virility and skilled performance. Montemurro (2021) found that being able to satisfy a woman's sexual appetites and desiresespecially by "giving" orgasms-was high on the list. however, the same heteromasculinity contributes to a "phallocentric imperative" that undermines women's claims to clitoral stimulation (Wade, Kremer, and Brown 2005;Willis et al 2018).…”