Identifying the measurements required to estimate rates of COVID-19 transmission, infection, and detection, using variational data assimilation

Abstract

We demonstrate the ability of statistical data assimilation (SDA) to identify the measurements required for accurate state and parameter estimation in an epidemiological model for the novel coronavirus disease COVID-19. Our context is an effort to inform policy regarding social behavior, to mitigate strain on hospital capacity. The model unknowns are taken to be: the time-varying transmission rate, the fraction of exposed cases that require hospitalization, and the time-varying detection probabilities of new asymptomatic and symptomatic cases. In simulations, we obtain estimates of undetected (that is, unmeasured) infectious populations, by measuring the detected cases together with the recovered and dead - and without assumed knowledge of the detection rates. Given a noiseless measurement of the recovered population, excellent estimates of all quantities are obtained using a temporal baseline of 101 days, with the exception of the time-varying transmission rate at times prior to the implementation of social distancing. With low noise added to the recovered population, accurate state estimates require a lengthening of the temporal baseline of measurements. Estimates of all parameters are sensitive to the contamination, highlighting the need for accurate and uniform methods of reporting. The aim of this paper is to exemplify the power of SDA to determine what properties of measurements will yield estimates of unknown parameters to a desired precision, in a model with the complexity required to capture important features of the COVID-19 pandemic.

Modeling COVID-19 epidemic trends and health system needs leading to projections for developing countries: a case study of Thailand

“…We use an extended compartmental model framework (6) to investigate COVID-19 epidemic trends and health systems needs in Thailand. The model framework consists of four stages: susceptible, exposed, infected, and recovered, and focuses on forecasting epidemic trends and hospital needs.…”

An Extended SEIR Model with Vaccination for Forecasting the COVID-19 Pandemic in Saudi Arabia Using an Ensemble Kalman Filter

“…The Reference [44] proposed an EnKF for estimating unmeasurable state variables and unknown parameters of a SIRV model, which takes into account the circulation of free coronavirus in the environment. In the context of variational data assimilation methods, the Reference [45] performed parameter estimation and predictions using a SIR model, while [46] proposed a modified SEIR model that distinguishes between symptomatic and asymptomatic, and conducted observation sensitivity experiments to identify suitable observing strategies. However, these studies did not consider the impact of vaccination on the pandemic spread.…”

Mathematical models to study the biology of pathogens and the infectious diseases they cause

“…Some additions include stochasticity ( Tornatore et al., 2005 ), spatial structure ( Keeling, 1999 ), heterogeneity within the population such as different age groups ( Franceschetti and Pugliese, 2008 ), and vaccination strategies ( Shulgin et al., 1998 ). To forecast demand for healthcare resources, the SIR model may also be expanded to account for symptomatology, disease surveillance, hospitalization, and mortality ( Armstrong et al., 2021 ; Wong et al., 2020 ). Agent-based simulations, which describe the behaviors of individuals moving geographically and contacting each other using rules that mimic the behaviors of people in the real world, can be used to study more complex scenarios ( Carley et al., 2006 ).…”