Identifying habitats at risk: simple models can reveal complex ecosystem dynamics

Abstract

The relationship between ecological impact and ecosystem structure is often strongly nonlinear, so that small increases in impact levels can cause a disproportionately large response in ecosystem structure. Nonlinear ecosystem responses can be difficult to predict because locally relevant data sets can be difficult or impossible to obtain. Bayesian networks (BN) are an emerging tool that can help managers to define ecosystem relationships using a range of data types from comprehensive quantitative data sets to expert opinion. We show how a simple BN can reveal nonlinear dynamics in seagrass ecosystems using ecological relationships sourced from the literature. We first developed a conceptual diagram by cataloguing the ecological responses of seagrasses to a range of drivers and impacts. We used the conceptual diagram to develop a BN populated with values sourced from published studies. We then applied the BN to show that the amount of initial seagrass biomass has a mitigating effect on the level of impact a meadow can withstand without loss, and that meadow recovery can often require disproportionately large improvements in impact levels. This mitigating effect resulted in the middle ranges of impact levels having a wide likelihood of seagrass presence, a situation known as bistability. Finally, we applied the model in a case study to identify the risk of loss and the likelihood of recovery for the conservation and management of seagrass meadows in Moreton Bay, Queensland, Australia. We used the model to predict the likelihood of bistability in 23 locations in the Bay. The model predicted bistability in seven locations, most of which have experienced seagrass loss at some stage in the past 25 years providing essential information for potential future restoration efforts. Our results demonstrate the capacity of simple, flexible modeling tools to facilitate collation and synthesis of disparate information. This approach can be adopted in the initial stages of conservation programs as a low-cost and relatively straightforward way to provide preliminary assessments of.nonlinear dynamics in ecosystems.

Dynamic heterogeneity: a framework to promote ecological integration and hypothesis generation in urban systems

“…8). Bayesian Network models are important tools in decision science and have gained attention as important tools for probabilistic evaluation of management outcomes in ecological systems (McCann et al 2006;Leigh et al 2011;Maxwell et al 2015).…”

Spatial analysis of carbon isotopes reveals seagrass contribution to fishery food web

“…Australian marshes are located high in the intertidal zone and are inundated only infrequently (Hollingsworth and Connolly 2006), potentially limiting detrital export (Connolly 1999). Although saltmarsh grass is likely to be highly productive, the total aerial cover of saltmarsh in the study area (7 km 2 ; Waltham 2009) is only 17% of that of seagrass (Maxwell et al 2015).…”

Lignes directrices pour l’application des critères et catégories de la Liste Rouge des Écosystèmes de l’UICN version 1.0

“…À ce stade, le degré d'accumulation temporelle et spatiale des données et prédictions peut être révisé pour faire correspondre la dynamique de l'écosystème au contexte de modélisation. Lorsque les données manquent, il est possible de déduire les processus et données à partir d'écosystèmes similaires (Maxwell et al 2015). Tout ceci doit être indiqué et commenté dans la documentation du modèle.…”