Identifying challenges for academic leadership in medical universities in Iran

Abstract

CONTEXT The crucial role of academic leadership in the success of higher education institutions is well documented. Medical education in Iran has been integrated into the health care system through a complex organisational change. This has called into question the current academic leadership, making Iranian medical universities and schools a good case for exploring the challenges of academic leadership. OBJECTIVES This study explores the leadership challenges perceived by academic managers in medical schools and universities in Iran. METHODS A qualitative study using 18 face-to-face, in-depth interviews with academic managers in medical universities and at the Ministry of Health and Medical Education in Iran was performed. All interviews were recorded digitally, transcribed verbatim and analysed by qualitative content analysis. RESULTS The main challenges to academic leadership could be categorised under three themes, each of which included three sub-themes: organisational issues (inefficacy of academic governance; an overly extensive set of missions and responsibilities; concerns about the selection of managers); managerial issues (management styles; mismatch between authority and responsibilities; leadership capabilities), and organisational culture (tendency towards governmental management; a boss-centred culture; low motivation). CONCLUSIONS This study emphasises the need for academic leadership development in Iranian medical schools and universities. The ability of Iranian universities to grow and thrive will depend ultimately upon the application of leadership skills. Thus, it is necessary to better designate authorities, roles of academic staff and leaders at governance.

Leadership challenges in health care organizations: The case of Iranian hospitals

“…HCOs, especially in low- and middle-income countries, are one of the institutions with the highest bureaucracy and the least effective management in the public sector. They have changed into highly centralized and hierarchical bureaucracies and have partial and boring executive rules, with permanent staff working in these institutions ( 39 , 51 ). Existence of numerous professionals in the hospitals that require specialized knowledge and skills makes the organization more complicated because people’s different positions retard the communication and makes it difficult to coordinate people and processes.…”

Academic leagues: a Brazilian way to teach about cancer in medical universities

“…The crucial role of leadership in medical education is well documented [ 25 , 26 ]. Although academic leadership faces challenges (as organizational issues, mismatch between authority and responsibilities, a boss-centred culture and low motivation [ 26 ], students find in Academic Leagues an important scenario of learning and practice. The management of AL is elected amongst student members each year.…”

Lived Experiences of Educational Leaders in Iranian Medical Education System: A Qualitative Study

“…In a successful educational institute the limit of authorities, responsibilities, policies, regulations, and strategic or operational programs are clear and at the hands of beneficiaries. The results of Bikmoradi et al (2010) study on the challenges of scientific management in the medical universities showed that scientific management in medical universities is very inefficient and the majority of components of management structure are uncertain and ambiguous ( Bikmoradi et al, 2010 ).…”