Identification and Evaluation of Neuropsychological Tools Used in the Assessment of Alcohol-Related Cognitive Impairment: A Systematic Review

Abstract

Background: Neuropsychological assessment is central to identifying and determining the extent of Alcohol-Related Cognitive Impairment (ARCI). The present systematic review aimed to synthesize and discuss the evidence appraising the neuropsychological tests used to assess ARCI in order to support clinicians and researchers in selecting appropriate tests for use with this population.Methods: We searched for studies investigating the psychometric, diagnostic and practical values of tools used in the screening, diagnosis, and assessment of Korsakoff's Syndrome (KS), Alcohol-Related Dementia (ARD), and those with a specific diagnosis of Alcohol-Related Brain Damage (ARBD). The following databases were searched in March 2016 and again in August 2018: MEDLINE, EMBASE, Psych-INFO, ProQuest Psychology, and Science Direct. Study quality was assessed using a checklist designed by the authors to evaluate the specific factors contributing to robust and clearly reported studies in this area. A total of 43 studies were included following the screening of 3646 studies by title and abstract and 360 at full-text. Meta-analysis was not appropriate due to heterogeneity in the tests and ARCI samples investigated in the studies reviewed. Instead, review findings were narratively synthesized and divided according to five domains of assessment: cognitive screening, memory, executive function, intelligence and test batteries, and premorbid ability. Effect sizes (d) were calculated to supplement findings.Results: Overall, several measures demonstrated sensitivity to the cognitive deficits associated with chronic alcoholism and an ability to differentiate between gradations of impairment. However, findings relating to the other psychometric qualities of the tests, including those important for the accurate assessment and monitoring of ARCI (e.g., test-retest reliability), were entirely absent or limited. Additionally, the synthesis of neuropsychological outcomes presented here supports the recent impetus for a move away from discrete diagnoses (e.g., KS, ARD) and the distinctions between them toward more broad and inclusive diagnostic conceptualizations of ARCI, thereby recognizing the heterogeneity in presentation.Conclusions: Based on the evidence reviewed, provisional recommendations for appropriate tests in each domain of assessment are presented, though further validation of most tests is warranted. Review findings can support efficient and evidenced-based test-selection and guide future research in this area.

Role of Patient Sex in Early Recovery from Alcohol-Related Cognitive Impairment: Women Penalized

“…It assesses different cognitive domains—attention and concentration, executive functions, memory, language, visuo-constructional skills, conceptual thinking, calculations, and orientation. Regarding all the screening tools for alcohol-related cognitive impairment, the Montreal Cognitive Assessment [36] has been rated comparatively as having the best psychometric qualities [37]. The maximum possible score is 30 points and the normal value ≥26 has recently been validated for patients with AUD [35].…”

A Collaborative Approach to Treatment of Alzheimer’s Disease from a Psychological Perspective

“…The importance of neuropsychological testing in matters of AD and alcohol consumption was delineated by Robert Heirene, Bev John, and Gereth Roderique-Davies. The authors reviewed the available data and agreed that cognitive screening is limited and is trumped by far by comprehensive neuropsychological testing following screening to ensure a correct diagnosis (31). The authors stated that neuropsychological testing establishes crucial characteristics of alcohol related cognitive decline that mostly includes a decline in executive functioning and episodic, autobiographical, procedural, and working memory.…”

Egocentric and Allocentric Spatial Memory in Korsakoff’s Amnesia

“…Another group of patients who are known to suffer from memory deficits, but also have spared memory capacities, are patients with Korsakoff's syndrome (KS); patients with this syndrome all display excessive memory disorders, lack of binding abilities, attention deficits and disorientation in time and place due to excessive alcohol abuse in combination with vitamin B1 deficiency (Kopelman, 2002;Tielemans et al, 2012;Arts et al, 2017; see Heirene et al, 2018 for a systematic review on the assessment of alcohol-related cognitive impairment including KS). Spatial memory performance in patients with this syndrome is characterized by a deficit in explicitly remembering spatial information (Holdstock et al, 1999;Kessels et al, 2000;van Asselen et al, 2005;Postma et al, 2006Postma et al, , 2018Kessels and Kopelman, 2012).…”