Identification and Assessment of Adherence-Enhancing Interventions in Studies Assessing Medication Adherence Through Electronically Compiled Drug Dosing Histories: A Systematic Literature Review and Meta-Analysis

Abstract

BackgroundNon-adherence to medications is prevalent across all medical conditions that include ambulatory pharmacotherapy and is thus a major barrier to achieving the benefits of otherwise effective medicines.ObjectiveThe objective of this systematic review was to identify and to compare the efficacy of strategies and components thereof that improve implementation of the prescribed drug dosing regimen and maintain long-term persistence, based on quantitative evaluation of effect sizes across the aggregated trials.Data sourcesMEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, the Cochrane Library, and PsycINFO were systematically searched for randomized controlled trials that tested the efficacy of adherence-enhancing strategies with self-administered medications. The searches were limited to papers in the English language and were included from database inception to 31 December 2011.Study selectionOur review included randomized controlled trials in which adherence was assessed by electronically compiled drug dosing histories. Five thousand four hundred studies were screened. Eligibility assessment was performed independently by two reviewers. A structured data collection sheet was developed to extract data from each study.Study appraisal and synthesis methodsThe adherence-enhancing components were classified in eight categories. Quality of the papers was assessed using the criteria of the Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions guidelines to assess potential bias. A combined adherence outcome was derived from the different adherence variables available in the studies by extracting from each paper the available adherence summary variables in a pre-defined order (correct dosing, taking adherence, timing adherence, percentage of adherent patients). To study the association between the adherence-enhancing components and their effect on adherence, a linear meta-regression model, based on mean adherence point estimates, and a meta-analysis were conducted.ResultsSeventy-nine clinical trials published between 1995 and December 2011 were included in the review. Patients randomized to an intervention group had an average combined adherence outcome of 74.3 %, which was 14.1 % higher than in patients randomized to the control group (60.2 %). The linear meta-regression analysis with stepwise variable selection estimated an 8.8 % increase in adherence when the intervention included feedback to the patients of their recent dosing history (EM-feedback) (p < 0.01) and a 5.0 % increase in adherence when the intervention included a cognitive-educational component (p = 0.02). In addition, the effect of interventions on adherence decreased by 1.1 % each month. Sensitivity analysis by selecting only high-quality papers confirmed the robustness of the model. The random effects model in the meta-analysis, conducted on 48 studies, confirmed the above findings and showed that the improvement in adherence was 19.8 % (95 % CI 10.7–28.9 %) among patients receiving EM-feedback, almost double the improvement in adherence for studies that did not inclu...

Measurement of adherence to BCR-ABL inhibitor therapy in chronic myeloid leukemia: current situation and future challenges

“…64 Furthermore, a recent meta-analysis suggested that electronic-monitoring feedback is potentially an effective approach to enhance patient adherence to medications. 65 In the current review on adherence to BCR-ABL inhibitors for the treatment of CML, only 3 studies measured adherence through an electronic monitor. Nevertheless, the L. Noens et al 442 haematologica | 2014; 99(3)…”

Prevalence and reasons for non-adherence to hyperlipidemia treatment

“…Particularly good results give those which provide patients with information regarding the drug taking, obtained through objective assessment of adherence [19]. One can hope that the implementation of an electronic patient's record, and electronic prescriptions in Poland, which is to happen within upcoming years, will enable doctors, pharmacists and patients closer insight into details of individual patient's pattern of medication taking.…”

The ESPACOMP and its role in promoting knowledge and competencies in the matter of patient adherence

“…To note, several founding members of ESPACOMP were involved in the European ABC project (www.abcproject.eu), which revisited the adherence taxonomy and reviewed determinants of medication adherence [1,2]. It also endorsed a meta-analysis on adherence-enhancing interventions through electronically compiled drug dosing histories, published a review on an educational framework for managing and supporting medication adherence in Europe and developed practical consensus-based policy solutions [3][4][5].…”